Caddyshack Bar & Grill — Restaurant in Plainsboro Township

I’ve been looking for good wings forever in this area. I got tired of Buffalo Wild Wings quick and every other place that offers wings I’m not a fan of. This place is through a neighborhood and near a golf course I believe. You may wonder where you are but don’t worry keep going you’ll find the spot!

I was surprised to see the their hours as they close at 10 PM. Interesting for a spot that advertises themselves as a sports bar. I called to confirm and yup 10 PM AND the kitchen closes at 9 PM. That’s some major KEY info right there especially for me because when I called it was 8:45 so I was too late.

The next time I wanted to go I had a meeting till 8:30. We left around 8:35 with an ETA of 8:55. Realized this was cutting it super close so we ordered on the phone and ended up sitting there to eat which they were cool with.

Food:

Wings - got the bucket of 20+ wings with Buffalo and Garlic Parm. You know it’s fresh when you see nice diced chunks of garlic all over the wings. Mhm. Best garlic parm wings I’ve had probably and I’m not a huge fan of the flavor either. Buffalo was classic and tasted great. These wings are juicy and crunchy. How a wing should be! And they have a decent amount of flavors to chose from. No Asian inspired though which are my favorite (they do have Teriyaki though but I’m not a fan of that).

Jalapeño Poppers - what you’d expect but good! I don’t know what sauce they had on the side but it was tasty with the poppers too!

Drinks - they have a solid beer selection. 6 beers on tap and a ton of choices from bottles. They had Dogfish Namaste which is one of my favorite beers too.

Atmosphere/Service:

The spot isn’t fancy at all. It kind of reminds me of a food hall at a water park or mountain. I have no complaints cause I came here for tasty wings, not the decor.

It’s probably not crowded too much but it seemed like they only had one bartender who was also acting as the server. She was doing her best at keeping it moving but if you’re impatient then you may get frustrated haha. She was super nice though and got us anything we requested.

They do have a decent amount of TVs so it’s not a bad spot to watch some games but since it closes at 10 PM, watching basketball doesn’t really work there. I’m sure football on Sundays would be...

I didn't go to Caddyshack to be abused by the waitress but thats exacty what happened on 04/28/2024 around 7-8 pm. I had the best day with my family and friends and thought ending the day here would be a blast. However, it was the exact opposite: after being mistreated by the waitress, my peace and happiness was totally distroyed. Right before leaving here, I raised my hand to tell the only waitress working that i wanted to close my tap and pay. But she got deeper trigered/traumatized and said, "I WILL NOT BE TREATED LIKE THIS" with pure anger. Thank god she said it in front of others who gave me sympathy (i hope they also stopped going after that day). I live 5 min walking distance from here but i don't think i will ever visit. So sad for caddyshack (i was a...

When it comes to bars, I often set the bar low. However, CaddyShack has proved, time and time again, that they represent a standard that exceeds expectations. This is not the kind of bar you want to wear a 3 piece suit and ask for your favorite 25 year old whisky, but if you are looking for exceptional service, captivating food, and memorable drinks, caddy shack is the best in the area. If you play Pool, the tables are often occupied by seasoned experts and novices alike. Overall, this establishment is a diamond in the rough, and if you find yourself at the bar, be sure to say hello to Emily and Caitlyn, they are the best...