Best Way Pizza Alum Bank — Restaurant in Pleasantville

I like to eat healthy. And this place offer seven different scrumptidlyumptious salad offerings. The salad was so big, I couldn't even finish the whole thing. $12.00. I drive all the way from Richland to Pleasantville (Alum Bank) to eat at this particular Bestway Pizza. I sure hope they open up one of these branches in Richland, maybe on Scalp Avenue (right Kate?).

Update 9/5/25: I keep going back to Alum Bank Best Wat Pizza to get my big salad fix (almost an hour round trip from Richland). They have the biggest, most tasty salads. George Constanza's "big salad" (Seinfeld) ain't got nothing on Alum Bank's Best...

If you like cheesy deliciousness in your pizza you found the place! There’s no skimping on the cheese, the sauce was perfect and the square crust was too. We also had the chicken ranch which was amazing and this had a thinner crust. Plus wings, I didn’t have them but heard they were great. I can’t speak to the atmosphere since this was a delivered order, the turnaround time and the team coming through in a clutch to help us with an event was truly appreciated. I’m not a local. We were visiting from out of town but if I were, this would be on my weekend go-to...

Been going here for the past year and the last 2 months has been garbage. We ask for lightly done pizza and it comes out looking like it was reheated hours ago. The side salad has NOTHING on it, went to complain and they did nothing, were rude as can be. When all your employees are 15 and can't do one job correctly, it's time for us to stop getting pizza here.i encourage others to stay away as well. A professional business would make better food and treat their customers with more respect. Went there Tuesday 10-30-2022 at 6:20 pm and have never had a...