Brothers Pizza of Lamar — Restaurant in Porter Township

I recently passed through town late on a Saturday evening and decided to try Brothers Pizza. I called in my order, and the food was delivered in just 15-20 minutes. I was very impressed, as this place exceeded the speed of many New York spots known for their quick service.

What I Ordered:

Italian Wedding Soup: It was flavorful without being too salty, and they didn’t skimp on the little meatballs. Cheddar Jalapeño Burger: Cooked medium rare, just as I requested, with extra onions on a crispy, toasted bun. The burger was magnificent. Fra Diavolo Linguine: The seafood was perfectly cooked, melting in your mouth rather than being rubbery, which can happen at other places. The sauce was unique, with a rich, chunky plum flavor cooked to perfection—not too hard, not too soft. Garlic Bread: Crispy with a lovely touch of Parmesan on top. Zeppoli: These had a delightful cinnamon sugar flavor, which was a unique twist that I loved. By the end of the night, there was nothing left. Everything was delicious!

Make sure to follow @TonySlice on Instagram for more food adventures from New York to Texas to California. Find me...

After waiting 40 minutes, we asked the waitress if our food was coming out. The cheesteak wrap was a lettuce wrap with a little bit of cold meat and unmelted cheese. The waitress said not to bother complaining bc the owner wouldn't really care. She said the cooks were new. The customers that came in after us were already eating pizza. I was told pizzas come out faster than the rest bc the owner makes them himself. People always encourage local business and we try but this was a major disappointment. The owner did send his son out to replace the meal bc "it will come out quickly this time" which it didn't. In the end it shouldn't have needed to get to that point. I don't typically do many reviews and when I do I try to make it positive. I felt compelled to share this experience. So in a nutshell, the staff was new, the food took forever and wasn't worth the...

Roadtrip from Boston to Chicago, searching for a good dinner place as traditional fast food wasn’t appetizing. Looked up places near the area we were passing by and Brothers Pizza of Lamar came up. Reviews were great & took the chance. SOOO GLAD WE DID!! Ordered sausage pizza and order of cheese fries. Some of the best NY style pizza I’ve had. Sauce - homemade, fresh and flavorful but not overwhelming. Crust- not thick nor thin, perfect chewiness with a good bite and crisp on the edges. Fries were heavenly… crispy outside with tender/mash potato inside. Received some garlic knots— pillowy soft and freshly made. Staff was super friendly, homey vibe made us feel comfortable while eating. Will be our must-go stop on our next road trip to NE. Thank you for a great meal and...