Libby's Catfish & Diner Eatery — Restaurant in Priceville

My friend and I were traveling from Priceville and since he had this place on his list to try, we stopped in.

Please understand that I am not a critical person. This genuinely was my personal experience here.

I have PTSD, and have a hard time sitting with my back to the open. There was a booth, but it needed clearing off. The server did not offer to clear the booth so that we could sit there - she stood staring while my friend and I debated on where I could sit that I would feel safe enough, and we finally just sat at a table in the middle of a wall. The server heard the entire conversation, and again, never offered to clear the booth which would have been appreciated.

A different server took our food order. I had the seafood something or another. One filet, some shrimp, deviled crab, and oysters. I cannot remember what my friend had, but it was different from what I ordered.

After receiving our food order from a different server ...

This was the blandest food I had ever tried to eat. Nothing had any true flavor to it, and ... it tasted like it had water in it. I don't know how to describe it. Every bite I took just tasted like water and bland and not good. I finally had to give up on eating it.

The original server came by once toward the end of our meal and asked if we needed drink refills. We said yes, and I said I needed more cocktail sauce. She brought my friend a refill and my cocktail sauce but didn't refill my tea.

I just wanted to pay and leave by then. So I didn't get more tea. It was not a good experience for me. And later that night I was quite violently ill. This was the only place I ate, so...

Great breakfast! I had been wanting to check out Libbey Restaurant for a long time, and finally, this morning, we just got up and went — no regrets at all! We arrived around 7:30 AM, and the parking lot was already almost full, which was a good sign. The place was busy inside, but the service was impressively fast and well-organized. The gentlemen at the front were incredibly polite and welcoming, which immediately set a positive tone. One of the things I appreciated most was the calm atmosphere — no loud music or background noise, just a comfortable, peaceful environment to enjoy breakfast. Now, the food! The portions are huge. I ordered two pancakes, expecting the standard size, but they were bigger than my hand! I asked our server if they used a premade mix, and she kindly explained they make everything from scratch. Later, she even came by to ask if I liked them — such thoughtful service. My eggs were cooked exactly how I ordered them, and my partner had two sausages, two eggs, hashbrowns, and toast — also a very generous and tasty portion. Everything was delicious, service was smooth and friendly, and the overall vibe was welcoming and relaxed. Highly recommend for anyone looking for a solid, satisfying breakfast spot with excellent service! Our plan is to...

Placed 2 separate 2go orders over the phone! I was not even close to Libby’s when I placed the order plus I had to make another stop before I got there! I ordered 3 whole catfish fillet plates with sides! Upon getting there after playing I asked for condiments I then go to grab my bags and noticed the fish was not fillet It had bones since the fish was sticking out of the containers! Fillet means no bones!!! The lady that took the order tried to Blame it on me umm no! She definitely needs to slow down they were extremely busy but she needs to pay attention because we had to wait longer for all 3 plates to be redone! They only re did the fish so the green tomatoes were not hot and fresh by the time we got the new order! The hush puppies were not hot!!! They also left out a piece of fish on one plate so I had to return back inside for that! It was all just a inconvenience and wasted a hour of our day for a pickup order! The lady was getting mad but it’s not my fault you guys didn’t check the plates before you gave them to us! And it’s also not my fault you don’t know what filet means! I mean we weren’t even offered anything free or some money back for the compensation just a big mess! I will not be returning for a while if I even decide to...