Casey's — Restaurant in Riverside Township

The pizza is okay, but our experience ordering through the app was awful. They got everything wrong, and I do not mean just customizations. They forgot half the standard toppings that were supposed to come on the brisket pizza. We also ordered an Italian wrap, which they literally handed me directly from the deli cooler. It was premade and packaged. I asked for NO mayo, but that didn’t matter, because this wrap comes with mayo. What is the point of allowing customers to say NO MAYO if that’s not really an option? This was my only special request. The worst part is that there wasn’t any meat, with the exception of a thin piece of salami. I truly believe they forgot to add the main ingredients, at least that is my hope, and that they aren’t actually selling these pathetic wraps on purpose. I do NOT recommend ordering any sandwiches or wraps at all. This store should be ashamed of themselves. They are very deceptive in the app leading customers to believe they are ordering fresh made-to-order food, rather than cold wraps and sandwiches found in the cooler of a convenient store that was made 10 hours earlier. My husband wouldn’t even eat it and he’s not picky at all with food. That says a lot. I’m only giving them 2 stars because the manager was nice. I used to like Casey’s, even preferred it over QT, but I am so put off by the deception that I deleted the app and have no...

It's a shame, because the food itself is not the problem. It's good Pizza and good Sandwiches. The donuts are pathetic.. But the food in general is tasty. HOWEVER... If you get good, or even adequate customer service at this location then you must have gotten there on the 3 days a year they probably have the rare good day. I often see several people standing in the waiting area trying to get their order correct for the third time. I have also seen all the employees verbally fighting in front of everyone. Not to mention that they are often not very friendly to the public.

If you order online, or by phone.. Good luck. DO NOT LEAVE without making sure the order is correct.

Lastly, if you are stopping to get a candy bar and a coke.. it might be okay, but you also might have to stand in a long line even if there are only two of you in line. They never open up a second...

A great place to fuel up and to grab a quick bite to go on your way into work. Applying discounts on fuel via the app for the pump is easy. When it comes ordering an actual meal for the family, we find that they have pretty tasty pizza. Having ordered from this location, Andover, and Augusta, their pizza hasn't really ever disappointed. Ordering on that app is painless. The breakfast pizza options can't be beat! Some of the best breakfast pizza I've had come from Casey's. For a long time, I didn't give Casey's pizza a shot because I figured it as typical gas station pizza. Nothing to write home about. But I tried it when some friends ordered from their local Augusta Casey's been a fan ever since. When it comes to the desserts, I'm a big fan of the frosted sugar cookies. They may be diabetes waiting to happen, but...