Pilgrim's Keep — Restaurant in Saint Marys

So, we decided to drive a little away from home to Pilgrims Keep in St Mary's. The wife called them to make sure we did not need reservations on a Friday evening. We were pleasantly surprised, when the attendant called back, after remembering we mentioned driving, that the Friday menu is different than other days. We witnessed this at the restaurant when another family walked in, and promptly walked out after learning about the all fish menu. We were actually looking forward to fish hence the 1hr drive. The attendant was very cordial and friendly. We ordered the Whiskey Daisy and Dark and Stormy for drinks. Also the Fish n chips (breaded cod) & (pan fried catfish) for our entrees, and the Apple Crisp for dessert. Everything was flavorful and had very adequate portions. The live music made the time fly by. Part of the entertainment is looking at the decorations and general "architecture" of the restaurant. The wife used the word "medieval" to describe it. Movies are our only point of reference, but it did have an "ancient" look to it. Will definitely mark Pilgrims Keep as a restaurant to visit...

AMAZING! Super cute place. The server/bartender downstairs was amazing and very kind. The food was out of this world good! The bread ad honey butter makes other places look bad lol I could’ve just eaten that it was SO GOOD! we went on the night they had fish on the menu. I had a fried catfish sandwich and fries. It was So soft and flavorful! I didn’t even need to put the sauce on it because it was that good! (The sauce is pretty tasty though) this is worth the drive to St. Mary’s. You get food that is so good, any drink from alcohol, soda, or choose from a coffee bar, and amazing service in a unique atmosphere. Definitely try it out! It’s so good it put some bigger name places to shame,...

Where do I start? Nothing short of Amazing! An easy 5 Star for sure. So much detail and work has gone into making your dining experience unforgettable. Wonderful service, food and drinks. Thursday and Saturday fun, light, live music that was perfect for dinner. Very reasonable prices for gourmet food. The fried chicken sandwich w bacon and cheese as well as burgers were seriously some of the best weve tasted! I can't say enough and so worth a visit to the quaint town of St Marys. What on earth are you waiting for?!!! 😍 PS ..Make sure to see the beautiful castle basement! What a great place to reserve for party or...