Gabe's Pizza — Restaurant in Sharpsville

Last week we bought 2 pizzas carryout...we live 25 min away so when we got home we saw both pizzas were totally wrong! They also were a sloppy mess! We called right away to let them know about how bad they were and were told to bring them back for exchange. It was 930 pm and as I said before we live 25 minutes away so we were told we could get them replaced the next time we came in and that they had a new girl who had trouble making the pizzas correctly. We came in this evening for our replacement pizzas but owner told us he would not honor the request..that we had to bring back bad pizzas the same day we got them. We would have if it hadnt been so late and if we lived alot closer!.We dont recommend this place anymore because of the bad customer service and the likleihood of getting a messed up order. We have had birthday parties there in the past and have gotten pizzas there 2 times month on average but will go to caseys in tipton from now on. We threw away the bad pizzas so it was an expensive ordeal but it just isnt worth the drive for the chance we may or may not get good...

I just spent $27 on a medium pizza, one order of breadsticks, and a drink. The food is okay, but I will never eat here again. The price gouging is ridiculous, I would’ve been willing to pay $20, maximum. I’m just totally shocked. The service was great, but don’t take advantage of your customers like that. It’s a little tiny pizza and 4 breadsticks with a drink that costed you guys 5 cents. It’s unacceptable to charge $27 for that. It’ll be the last time, unfortunately. Living in sharpsville it’s one of the only good places for pizza, looks like I’ll be ordering from the gas station down the road from now on. $11 for a LARGE pizza there,...

The pizza and bread sticks at Gabe's Pizza are absolutely delicious. Their pizza has plenty of toppings and lots of cheese. The staff is very friendly and will go above and beyond to make sure your order is cooked to perfection. The only reason I am only rating them four stars is because it is sometimes very difficult to place a take out order over the phone due to them not answering the phone when you call. If it weren't for that, Gabe's Pizza would easily be a five star...