Belluccio's — Restaurant in Sheffield

Overall a 9/10 and second best pizza ive had in my entire life, the service was extremely friendly and the atmosphere was unmatched. I will be recommending this place to everyone and their mothers, especially for their Pan🙏🏻

Update: Unfortunately our second visit here changes my previous review entirely. Ordered our food at 7 and was told it would be ready within 30 to 45 minutes, got there at around 7:50, when we got there we were not greeted and instead asked our order, i said the order and a few minutes later they bring it out without saying a word, im not one to nit pick typically but for a $100 order simple small talk would be appreciated. When i had paid they started to walk away immediately before we could ask for parmesan, when we did ask they tossed the bag on the counter with a handful and walked away ignoring both me and my friend wishing them a good night. The Food itself was not close to what it was last time and not something i would recommend, the cheese was hard, pizza had to be recut, not much sauce at all, and a bit light on all the meat toppings too. Overall id have to say this second experience was a complete opposite from the first time and overall left me extremely disappointed, unsatisfied,...

Belluccios 115 S Main St Sheffield IL 61361

I’m going to keep this review short and sweet, sweet like their sauce. The interior is clean and looks like a pizza joint. The plastic table clothes will make your arms sweat. So have proper table manners and keep your elbows off of the tables. The service is good I really liked our waitress.

What the heck is that dried out chalky pseudo bread stick concoction they serve as an app. Dreadful. I’m still parched! The pizza crust is like a communion wafer. I believe it is unleavened bread that is appropriate for the Easter season. The sauce is very sweet and sparse aiding in the dry communion wafer like texture of the crust. The toppings are fine and there is melted cheese on the pizza. Come on man cans of Coke. Really?

According To The Big Food Jerk.

There is a better pizza joint in town and they...

🍕 Belliccio’s Pizza – A Slice of Heaven in Sheffield, IL

From the moment we walked in, Belliccio’s delivered more than just pizza—it served up a full-on experience. The food? Absolutely amazing. Every bite was bursting with flavor, fresh ingredients, and that perfect balance of crispy crust and gooey goodness that makes you close your eyes and savor.

But what truly set this place apart was the staff. They didn’t just meet expectations—they soared above and beyond. Friendly, attentive, and genuinely kind, they made us feel like honored guests rather than just customers. Whether it was a thoughtful recommendation or a warm smile, their hospitality was unforgettable.

If you’re craving top-tier pizza with heartwarming service, Belliccio’s is the place to be. We’ll...