Little Sicily Pizza & Restaurant — Restaurant in Town of Alfred

The inside of the store was really hot, no AC, just a ceiling fan. Granted, we were there only 10-15 mins after 8 o'clock closing time, but they still let us order. The cashier man-handled the spare slices without gloves as she sorted thru a stack of pizza slices. We ate outside but there were no trash cans outside by the tables and chairs, and wanted to throw our box away but when we asked the workers closing up if they had a trash can (while I was holding a pizza box), they said no and went back to work despite the cashier handling clear trash bags shortly after placing our slices in the oven indicating that they already took the trash out to the dumpster (they still could have taken the box from us and just tossed it in the dumpster themselves. Thankfully, the food was really good, even for pizza slices that were likely kept in the display cabinet all day and then stored in a pile for a...

This is my favorite pizza place from Alfred to Hornell! Every thing I've gotten from here is amazing. Depending on who's working I get about 20 boneless wings in a dozen order. Their pizza is sweet yet crispy . The only downfall is there's no online menu. Ive had to call multiple times to ask what all they had on their menu besides pizza and how much the items were. Which can be irritating im sure as they are always busy. ....in 2023 that's a major let down. But the foods good and the staff are always very friendly. I asked for a paper menu with my delivery as I have before and none were delivered and I'm not driving to grab one or I wouldn't have ordered delivery. Hopefully they will bring me one with this order ❤️ great job...

Excellent pizza, terrific staff, and nice atmosphere. During the two years that my son attended Alfred State, this was a regular stop for me before heading back home. I would have a slice, then bring home a whole pizza . for the family, and in the freezer for leftovers. dfddOriginally being from the NYC area &(now a Rochester resident for the past 22 years), and having tasted pizza from many parts of the country, I consider myself a pizza connissiere (sp?; basically, I just love pizza.. and in my honest and impartial opinion , Little Sicily's pizza is excellent ! It reminds me so much of New York pizza, and having lived there most of my life,and I should know!!

Peace and Power to the...