Renny's Store & Deli — Restaurant in Town of Amenia

Stopped here on our way to Bash Bish Falls from the city looking for sandwiches. It's a cute mom & pop shop. Clean and very homey. There's no official house menu so you have to go in with the mindset of knowing exactly what you want. No craft chef here. My recommendation: get the roast beef with white American cheese LTO with horseradish mayo on the hard roll and you will not be disappointed! They have drinks and chips and other goodies in the store if you so wish. Girls were really nice and patient with me being unsure of...

Rennys deli IS the best deli around ! Their prices are the best around ! I always get breakfast bsec toasted on a butter roll with sp for breakfast and it always hits the spot . The employees are very friendly and family oriented which is amazing ! Once you’re a regular they know your order,face,name ! They truly make you feel like you’re apart of the community and...

Renny's Store&Deli has been my family go-to since day one of me moving to Dover Plains all them years ago. It's family owned and family respects the customers who come in to buy the products they sell. And not to mention they are a family that we...