Manhattan Bagel Cafe - Mastic Beach — Restaurant in Town of Brookhaven

Hobart Elementary here!!

Mastic Beach Bagels isn't just serving up delicious bagels - they're also serving our community! As a local educator, I'm impressed by their commitment to supporting students' learning.

They provide coupons for free bagels as incentives for our students to continue working on ELA and math at home through a program called MyPath. It's been a fantastic motivator, and the kids absolutely love it.

The bagels themselves are top-notch - fresh, chewy, and available in a variety of flavors. But what really sets Mastic Beach Bagels apart is how they've integrated themselves into our educational community. They understand that sometimes, a free bagel can be the extra push a student needs to keep working hard.

Whether you're a local looking for a great breakfast spot or an educator searching for creative ways to motivate students, Mastic Beach Bagels is worth checking out. They're proof that great food and community support can go...

This place was pretty bad. I don’t write many reviews but the customer service in store and on the phone was not good at all, I had to write something. But not only that, the food was....yikes! Bagels were kind of flat and super dry. There was a lot of pepper practically dumped on the bagel sandwiches, not much bacon, eggs weren’t fluffy, but very flat and dry, cheese was nonexistent. Home fries were just potatoes (no onions or anything extra lol) that were again covered in pepper. Lastly there were 2 sad looking unseasoned slices of avocado on my bagel. I don’t mean to be insulting but we probably will never go back here because the food was so bad. Good luck if you do go here maybe they’ll get better, although I’m not very confident that...

Good food good prices the owner tries his best to deliver the exact order perfectly, personally I am very simple but I saw how one of my friends asked for an equation lol for a bagel egg sandwich that was so detailed that one of the employees handed his phone in order to the owner because I believe that the owner actually had his order style memorized- that's impressive considering they probably have hundreds of orders daily from all walks of life ages you name it- large Indoor seating spaced out well so you can have a good conversation I would actually say if your doing a one on one informal business meeting this may actually be better than many other places for a morning appointment with coffee...