Montauk Pizzeria — Restaurant in Town of Brookhaven

We walked in- it looked like a party was going on with the staff. A woman behind the counter was sitting on it and making out with another employee, loud music blaring. It smelled faintly like weed and most of the women were dressed with their bellies hanging out… not appetizing. No food available over an hour before closing time. Everyone scattered like roaches when we walked in & the cook finally came up and asked us what we wanted. It was so weird and dirty in there & I felt so unwelcome. I felt like I stepped into an alternate universe. No one greeted us even though there were about 8 employees and they all stared at us like we had two heads. Never going back but my boyfriend and I did get a good laugh out of...

The pasta is good there I always get their seafood combo or...

The quesadilla was so cheesy and yummy...