Nonna's Pizzeria — Restaurant in Town of Carmel

I ordered delivery on line one day and I was extremely disappointed. I called them today to order pizza, thinking I was calling Zach's Pizza which was the previous establishment, not knowing they had changed hands and that's where Miraggis now was. W recording picked up first telling me this call would be recorded. Oddly intrusive for a pizzeria. They answered the phone abruptly like I was bothering them or I called the wrong number out something. I actually had to ask them if this was a pizzeria that I had called. I felt very awkward. I placed a simple order for 2 pizzas. They didn't seem to understand what I was ordering. When I finally made it clear to them I hung up the phone and they called me back moments later and I couldn't understand what the individual was saying. I cancelled the order because I could only imagine what I would end up picking up. I wasnt ready for that headache. I don't think they will do very well. They won't be getting my business anymore, I'll...

Edit: If you’re looking for some run of the mill slice, this might be your go to.

If you’re looking for a salad, this might not be your choice. Ordered a Cesar salad with grilled chicken, and the chicken is the only thing I ate. Why? I could tell the chopped romaine lettuce was old, browned and dried out. Quite sad. You may ask why did I order a salad here, because I was ordering where everyone else was.

Also, the croutons... kind of sad, too. A pizzeria should have the tools to make semi decent croutons out of day old bread. Toss diced bread with olive oil, salt, pepper, garlic, onion, and boom. Bake till crispy brown.

Bottom line, don’t go with the salad. Stick with the usual...

I moved to Mahopac from Carmel about a year and a half ago, my old go to pizza place in Carmel was Sals Pizza but unfortunately they don’t deliver this far out so I gave Zach’s a try after being continuously disappointed with the other pizzerias in the area. Zach’s Pizza is absolutely delicious, they get it right every single time no matter what you order. Even the employees are fantastic and always very helpful, especially the girls. 10/10...