Talk of the Town Pizzeria — Restaurant in Town of Chateaugay

Visited the pizzeria on a Thurs evening directly after work with a buddy. We ordered 1 Lg 3-topping pie + a mound of chicken wings. I was a little apprehensive as the place was empty of people, but it was an off night, and the pizzeria is located in a very small but friendly town. The manager, his name escapes my memory, was very welcoming, informative, helpful, and made us feel comfortable immediately upon our entrance. When the food arrived, the pie looked fresh and perfectly timed from the oven. The pile of wings were smoking with just the right amount of sauce lathered about. Now, I'm kinda a spoiled snob when it comes to great Italian foods because my Italian girl owns an Italian bistro and pizzeria restaurant in lower NY, and she's a phenomenal cook who cooks with love. So when I am "unloyal" and eat Italian food not created from her hands, I tend to become a seasoned critic.... Anywho, both the pie and the wings were devoured like 2 Norse vikings at a victory feast only without the liquid Mead and Beowulf in attendance. The pie was very delicious with healthy portions of the 3-toppings and cheese. The sauce wasn't overpowering but complimentary to the blended trio with the correct amount of cheese all baked in this circular pool of dough. I shall return, as MacArthur once said, whether as a solo dining traveler or with an invasion of my fellow compatriots of hungry, rowdy Norsemen. Thanks...

We come here from time to time and usually have a good experience. Tonight however couldn't have been more of the opposite! We ordered their special, which is a large 3 topping pizza and 20 wings for $30. I ordered the wings first so that they would be an appetizer and about 5-10 minutes later ordered the pizza. The pizza shows up almost 45 minutes later looking like it have been dropped on the floor and placed it back on the pan. One half of it looked great, the other half was missing the majority of the dough and literally was just toppings. They said they could either remake it or give me 15% off my bill if I take it. I decided to take the pizza since I figured it would be another 45 minutes before I got another. Mind you we were the only table dining in, and watched well over dozen people get their food while we waited and had nothing. The wings arrived Even later than the pizza, however, they were at least excellent as usual.

To add insult to injury, when I paid for my food the 15% wasn't even deducted.

If you're in the chateaugay area, go to smokehouse, the Cherry knoll or even Wendy's before stopping here,...

Wo ordered a pulled pork with pineapple and got pulled pork with pineapple and jalapeño peppers. We called and told them we didn't order the jalapeños. When we returned the pizza for the one we ordered we were told they would give us a 15% discount. That was their 2nd and last chance of us ever ordering from them again.

We didn't order the specialty pizza, we told you we wanted a large pizza with pulled pork and half with pineapple. Your person went to the back to relay our message and was immediately back out with nothing you could do but give us a 15% discount. This was the order takers fault, not ours. We had no clue what is on your menu. That was our 2nd and last time. How much would it have cost to make a new pizza for us? Less than losing our business? Less than the bad review? More than the...