Mamma Grace Pizzeria & Restaurant — Restaurant in Town of Deerpark

This was truly one of the best pizza's I have had in a long while. I came up to Sparrow bush for a quick getaway from NYC. On our first day we came across Mamma Grace Pizzeria on our way to the rental property and noticed quite a crowd of people outside. We decided then and there to try the spot during our week long day.

Boy! I am glad we made the right choice. We ordered the Charlie Special pie and some wings. The pie was made perfectly! The crust was crispy yet a little thick, which is a rarity. Usually one associates crispy crusts with thin pizza. Charlie Special contains Broccoli Rabe, garlic amongst other ingredients. The veggies were fresh and there was ample amount of garlic (my fav). The sauce (sweet) balance the entire Pizza.

I am glad I got to try their pizza and very happy that it happened on the last few days of our trip! Otherwise, I would have gained quite a bit of weight eating there everyday.

Thanks guys. Hope to be back soon and making your shop...

I have been waiting over a year to try this place. I figured a Tuesday night would be a good time to try the food. The positive is that the place appears to be very clean and the staff are very pleasant. There were a decent amount of people picking up food and eating pizza there. I have not had a calzone since 2019 and we decided to order one and also have a plain slice also. The slice was fine, nothing that would make me want to gobble down several but it was okay. Now to the calzone. The size for the price was fine. Number one, it was not heated long enough but there were no cold spots. The bottom of it was very dark and almost burned. There were spots where the dough was not fully cooked. The calzone was a disappointment. The sauce that came with it was not very good and I just did not find it well seasoned. After this, we both agreed that we need not ever return based on this visit. I saw many positive reviews and was hoping for much better. You...

What an amazing place haven’t had real NY/ Brooklyn style pizza in a very long time , Their Calzones are to die for. First off very fresh ingredients used on every single item , calzone was crispy crunchy and cheesy all in one bite.we then also got a veal Marsala and asked if it can be made into a hero ,which was excellent!!! compliments to the chef. We also tried a variety of different gourmet slices they were all delicious. My favorite slice had to be the Hot Honey Chicken Bacon Ranch. Compliments to the staff and pizza man for carrying out an absolutely wonderful product and service. We felt like family nothing less. There is scarcity of authentic pizza Joints nationwide but MAMA GRACE sure didn’t disappoint 11/10 we are definitely coming back in the upcoming days,weeks,months,and years , you’ve gained a customer forever. What a deliciously lovely...