Andy's Pizza — Restaurant in Town of Elba

My parents moved to Elba, but we hadn't been to Andy's in years, so we figured it was time to give them a try. Well, we are so glad we did. We've been going there lots ever since we tried their wings and pizza because both are great and the quality is consistent. The only suggestion I have is that you ask them to make your pizza saucy. We used to find their pizzas a tad dry, so we asked the guy working their to make sure ours was saucy and he came through for us. Moreover, he remembers us now, so he basically tells us he'll make the pizza the way we like before we even ask him. If you either haven't tried Andy's or haven't been recently, do yourself a favor and try them the next time you have a...

Driving home to Rochester I saw the shop outta the corner of my eye; starving, I pulled in. Owner was friendly & helpful. Ordered the small steak sub to pound down on my travels. FANTASTIC Sammy! Grilled roll set the stage, terrific taste, great ingredients, checked every single box you wantd. Washed it down with a cane sugar coke in the old style bottle. Will probably stop in too often on my travels - great stuff, a hidden gem....

Way to expensive & so not worth it. Pizza was under cooked, very small amount of sauce, very small amount of cheese & little amount of toppings. Pizza was super thin. Wings were small & definitely not hot like I asked. I am sorry but I won't be ordering here again. The front area is also very dirty & not pleasant to look at. Cob webs every...