North Star Tavern — Restaurant in Town of Elma

Great ole tavern with that "down home" feeling. You may not know anybody going in but you feel comfortable among everyone. It was packed Friday night and after 2 snow blow/shovel days looked like all bee-lined here to get out and made it feel alive and fun. We started at the bar (standard move) and they got Genny so all was well. They have a great mixed menu and their Pierogi was delicious along with coconut shrimp. First timers so went beef on weck (perfect and plenty with good warm fries) and prime rib sandwich which my wife enjoyed (good portion as well). We will be back and try other items for sure.So many delicious sounding items. Nice touch was seeing the owner come into the room and stop and chat and thanking everyone.He had awesome friendliness and sincerity. The only negative was we felt we were being rushed a bit to open up the table. Perhaps next time eat at the cool bar instead. But if you like "old school/down home" you have to go to this local...

6 retired nurses who all worked together met for lunch and we had a wonderful time! Food, atmosphere, service were more than expected! Wide variety of choices and prices are average with these days. I tried something new and different. I was not disappointed! Friends all enjoyed their food, some had the specials of the day. Homemade soups, noodles were excellent! It was a cool afternoon so we sat inside. There is a beautiful outside area in the back with a huge fire pit. Leaving, I explored back there and the sun had come out and two ladies were enjoying sitting in the sun with wine and appetizers. They said it was lovyin the sun. Plenty of parking and friendly staff! Thank for such a nice experience for our time together! Didn't take pictures - having too much fun! Reservations are a good idea.They put us at a round table, which...

Cool place we stumbled on. There was a minimal wait but they took us without reservations. You can tell they care about their product. Everyone was friendly and helpful. Food was full of flavor. My husband had shepherds pie. Mashed potatoes were smooth. Nice layer of cheese on top. It was a good mix of everything. My stepson had beef weck. It was served with fries and spicy horseradish. Meat was juicy. He enjoyed the bun that had a salt mixture on top of it. My dad had a kielbasa rueben with fries. It was well made. Everything tasted homemade including the kielbasa. I had 2 potato and cheese perogies with a side of green beans. They were fresh and amazing. The peorgies taste just like my grandmother's. FYI looks like you are pulling up to someone's house and parking in...