Five Pillars Supper Club - Restaurant and Banquet Halls — Restaurant in Town of Fredonia

The meal started out great with a salad and cheese curds but went down hill from there. I had the broasted chicken with onion rings, mixed veggies and applesauce. I couldn't eat the chicken. Although it seemed moist it was rubbery, the breading had NO flavor and had un-chewable bits. The onion rings looked delicious but they didn't taste like onion at all, bits were raw and the breading had no flavor. The veggies were a pale, mushy mess and I couldn't even try them. My son had the chicken tenders and fries. It also came with the horrible veggies. The chicken, again, was rubbery and had no flavor. The fries were, thankfully, good. What an expensive disappointment! Do they not season anything??? We will not be going back. Update: 5 Pillars replied to my review telling me I should have told someone about the bad food. Well, can they imagine all 3 of us telling them we didn't like our food? Also, our server never even batted an eye when we told her we didn't need boxes yet our plates were still full of food. I probably would have said something if she would have said "you haven't eaten anything. Didn't you like the food?" But she didn't and I was too embarrassed for the restaurant and myself to complain about everything. We just paid the bill, tip...

My hubby and I (Tom and Sherry) stop at this restaurant when we return from visiting our daughter and her family that live in DePere. Hwy 57 is our favorite way to take home because we can stop halfway through and dine at one of our favorite places for dinner. We're usually there on Sat or Sun nights and love the food, the people and the atmosphere. It's the good ol' "supper club" set up, and the bar is large for many people to enjoy their pre-meal cocktails. Jim makes the best Old Fashioned around! We LOVE their Prime Rib as our top choice and the Salad Bar is well stocked with many selections. I can never finish my meal...it's healthy portions of everything...but then I have great leftovers for another time. We've never had to wait long for a table. They have a fireplace in the dining room that's used in cold weather and it makes you feel so welcome and warm. The view out of the windows is of beautiful farm land and they have ample parking. They also have banquet space and hold many occasions there. But here's the rest of the story...their prices are VERY affordable! I don't know of another restaurant around that offers the food value for their prices! The staff is friendly (family) and it's just a good choice. Hope to see you there sometime-we live...

I've eaten at this restaurant several times hoping the food would be as great as it was after one of my first visits a few years ago. It's unfortunately gotten worse. My baked cod was undercooked. My burgers are either burned or served raw. We ordered dinner last night for a special celebration, the wait was over an hour but decided to wait anyways. We got our food home and the burger and bacon was burned. We took it back asking for medium rare but when we got it home it was now raw. I thought they were just messing with us at this point. I called in and Mary (the owner) answered. Her reasoning is that a burger still cooks while in the Styrofoam container. You would think after owning this place for over 22 years a medium rare burger would be an easy dish to cook but apparently it isn't. They need a decent cook and thermometer, not sure who's cooking or why the food is so inconsistent but let's just say the food is as bad as the exterior is run down. Take your business elsewhere is what I advise, you'll be...