Oak Leaf Cafe & Bakery Penn Yan — Restaurant in Town of Milo

Whenever we visit Penn Yann and need to grab lunch, this is our go-to place for food. We do shop at the store, which is amazing with all their options. This time, we went in for a late lunch before running more errands. Between us, we tried an assortment, and everything was delicious! It's all made in their little Cafe. I tried the Southwest Salad, which was the special, my wife had the Oven Roasted Chicken Panini, and we grabbed a bowl of Potato & Ham Chowder soup to bring home. The Salad was delicious, with the dressing being just the right amount of spice. The sandwich was perfectly made. The soup was perfect for the chilly day we stopped in. I've tried multiple items on the menu and everything is delicious. They have wholesome and healthy options for anyone whose looking for specific...

We stumbled on this devine Amish cafe which is also part of a larger grocery and butchers market. Sadly we just missed breakfast but lunch didn’t disappoint! I had the cheesesteak panini cooked to steaming perfection with sumptuous chopped steak, melted cheese and sautéd peppers - just the right amount. My wife had a grilled chicken spinach salad which she enjoyed although too much chicken to finish. Then the highlight was dessert! The Boston cream pie frye was out of this world! Could not be happier with this lunch discovery as we explored Seneca Mill and Falls - about 15...

I sent an email to Oak Leaf Café on Thursday evening inquiring if it would be possible to order soup for 15 people to be picked the next morning around 11:30. I was wishing to receive an answer but didn't have my hopes too high since it was such short notice. To my surprise, Phil responded to my email within 30 minutes stating that it would be possible and that I would receive confirmation the next morning. At 8:30 on Friday morning, I received a phone call confirming my order! I picked it up at the agreed time. It was delicious and a great hit...