Dustin's Pizzeria — Restaurant in Town of Murray

Hidden in a little knook in the town of Holley is Dustin's Pizzeria. They were steadily busy with takeouts while we waited for our pie, although there is plenty of room for dining in. The sauce to cheese ratio complemented each other's flavor to perfection. The sauce tasted homemade and had hints of oregano and basil. I don't know if it is a homemade sauce recipe, as I did not ask, but it brought back memories of a New York City pizza we ate while exploring the Statue of Liberty. Yummmm. Dustin's Pizzeria crust was neither too thick nor too thin, crispy on the bottom, and held up nicely to the thick cheese and pepperoni toppings. We were surprised to find that both the flavor of the food and the price of it far exceeded the other guy that only sometimes treats you like family. When we go again, we will dine in and eat that pizza as it was intended, hot out...

It's two star solely because I haven't tried the food. I just moved to brockport and found Dustin's looking for a more local pizza place. Upon ordering for delivery the employee seemed very short and annoyed I was ordering. But that's fine everyone has a bad day sometimes. After finishing my order he asked where it was going and I said my address in brockport. The employee quickly said we don't deliver to brockport and hung up on me. Had he stayed on the line I would've switched to pick up but I guess there wasn't time for that or the option. Very disappointed as I've seen good reviews for this place and it was recommended but one bad employee can really turn you off a place. I may try Dustin's another time but as far as first impressions it...

Always order on the phone and theyre always very polite. They also do less contact which is very helpful during this time. You just pay over the phone with your credit card then let them know to leave it outside for you on a chair or whatever you have outside for them to lay it on. Very convenient! Food is delicious. The only thing I don't like is their pizza crust is too thick and burnt for my liking and pizza dough is thick too but other then that its good! Wings are perfect size for me. Chicken dinner plate is great too! Their calzones are really good just again the dough is a little too thick for my taste and not a lot of sauce inside or meat. They're quick on their delivery and very informative if they...