Sam's Diner HOLLEY — Restaurant in Town of Murray

Horrible food and prices. I went there for breakfast with a couple guys. Eggs were runny. My potato was smashed with the skin on and partially burnt on the outside, leaving the inside cold and raw. Bacon was as thin as a potato chip. My silver wear was also very dirty as you can see most of the restaurant is not well cleaned or kept.

The food wasn't horrible, but it wasn't good at all. The food I'd give 2/5 stars. However, the price of the food was insane. 7.50 for eggs and bacon? I ended up paying $27 for 3 people which is ridiculous for breakfast.

Never going to this over priced hill billy dive again.

EDIT: Thanks for your reply.

I am 100% sure I was at Sam's Diner in Holley NY on July 9th at about 10am. I have been there many times usually for the chicken finger dinner. This was my first breakfast.

I asked the waitress for scrambled eggs, bacon and toast. she also gave me a potato. The other 2 guys I was with got the exact same.

Yes the potato had skin on it. I didn't ask for 3 eggs, so I'd assume it was 2, since it didn't look like much. Yes, my butter knife was seriously dirty also. We also ordered 2 cups of coffee and 1 water.

The bill was $27. I asked the lady at the register who is also on your facebook page in the santa claus picture. I said, "can it really be 7.50 for eggs and bacon?" she got red in the face and said "yes". It was 7.50, 7.50, 7.50 and 3.30 for the 2 coffees combined.

That is 25.80 + tax. Which is an additional $2 making it $27.

So why does it cost me 7.50 PLUS tax?! This was a simple breakfast.

So it's $2 for a potato? And no, I didn't see the prices on the menu. Because I didn't order from a menu like you said I did. In fact, we didn't get menus and she came right to our table after bringing drinks and said, "you know what you want".

I said scrambled eggs, toast, and bacon.

So maybe you should give menus and reconsider charging people $2 for an uncooked, non...

Finished off our hike in Holley at this awesome little diner. Parking is in front of the diner which is located in a postcard perfect town that looks like a movie set. We were offered lunch and breakfast menus in the afternoon which is nice to have choices.

I ordered the tuna club which was really good with fresh tuna salad and crispy toast. My lunch companion got the Monte Cristo which the waitress suggested he eat with syrup. I've never seen him finish a sandwich before his fries before. That's really saying something because this place honestly has the best fries. Crispy and maybe battered and seasoned? Not sure but they're the best.

Friendly service and great prices round out this dining experience. Definitely...

Excellent! Both the food and the service here are above average. The service here is always friendly and the waitstaff make you feel like family. (the best kind ☺) The food is fantastic, especially the breakfast menu (which is served all day). The portions are so large, it's hard to eat it all. And of course the prices are very reasonable. If you haven't eaten here, you don't know what you're missing! By the way, I travel a lot, and this diner is one of my favorite...