Pulcini’s Ice Cream — Restaurant in Town of Palmyra

We stopped for ice cream, my husband ordered a black cherry ice cream in a cone, for me. It was absolutely horrible 😢 Tasteless, it didn't taste like ice cream, it was very bland. If it weren't for the cherry it would have been worst! I did try to eat it, but it was not ice cream.... I ended up throwing it out. I should probably have gone to the window and tell the owner as to my disappointment, but it was busy and I didn't bother.

I've been to this place once before and I enjoyed the ice cream. I don't know what brand ice cream they purchased this time, but it was Not good. Hope the owners will try this...

This ice cream was awesome. Top five ice creams I have ever had in my life. The coconut one was super flavorful. I think it was chocolate extravaganza with the coconut was awesome. The lemon meringue one was awesome. The caramel was awesome and the banana one was awesome.

As you can see, we eat a lot of ice cream in our family so we know what we’re talking about. I would 100% come here again! Also, it was really nice, They had a really wide variety of flavors and everything we tasted was super quality. I just wish I was going be Around longer...

We are from South Carolina and this will be a place we always stop at when we are in Upstate NY. Very clean and a safe family environment. It's away from the road so children can play in the grass while the adults enjoy their icecream and socialize. There is an abundance amout of parking . THE ICECREAM 🍦, OMGosh!!!! The servings are H.U.G.E !!! The flavors are rich and creamy and the selection seemed endless. Floats, sundaes, shakes, cones and the list goes on. The best for me is that they offer gluten free icecream. ...