Tally Ho Supper Club — Restaurant in Town of Round Lake

Unfortunately we did not even get served after waiting close to 2 hours! We were told it would be 45 minutes for a table. We were offered to stay at the table in the bar we were sitting at to order food which we were happy to do at first however, after surveying the room, the owner was bartending and the dining room was very behind. My husband ordered a simple round of drinks and got them from the bar. The owner would tell us he would be right over to take our order but then he would loose himself in the dining room asking how everyone’s dinner was and it was as if he was avoiding the bar area when he could. I also heard him mentioning to a couple people waiting around the bar that they could come behind the bar and make their own drinks (so tacky!) The owner finally got himself back behind the bar and said directly to us “hey folks we appreciate your patience, I will be right over to take your order”. He then tells the guy at the bar he was going to go take our order and then the owner said ‘oh wait, let me fill your drink first’. The customer mentioned he was still working on his drink and the owner still insisted on made him a drink and then STILL didn’t come to our table after even saying it out loud that he would be right over!!! Guess what the owner did next?? You guess it, he went back out into the dining room walking around talking to the seated tables! We were fuming. We finally decided after this happened again that we had, had enough of this. Seriously embarrassed for the owner because he clearly cannot prioritize what needs to happen to keep things flowing. This is so important when running a restaurant. We waited all that time and we were brought a relish tray by one of his helpers but that was it. Nobody even brought us a menu, let alone take our order. Needless to say, we drove back to our resort with empty stomachs and much disappointment. You never know who will walk through your doors. Everyone should be treated as though they are your friend. It is people like us that can make or break places like this. The message is simple here. If you cannot seat people to serve them food then please just be up front and tell them you are full for the evening. We would have rather been told this instead of wasting 2 hours of...

Numerous issues with this badly managed restaurant... First, I found their menu on-line, it looked reasonably priced for a supper club. Upon arrival with reservations, cocktails at table with tiny portioned "relish tray", if you can it that, which the owner was SO proud of for some reason. Then proceeded to look over menu with astonishment at pricing mostly double of the on-line version. Should have left at that point, but didn't, we were hungry and, no other restaurants around as alternate. Secondly, owner was loud and rude to a newer employee numerous times right in the middle of the restaurant; so unprofessional. Next, I ordered a Lamb special of the night, unfortunately it did not come with a 'saw' to cut it. The owner did agree to replace it with other choice. I wanted something quick as the other 4 in our party was finishing up with their mediocre meals. So, I ordered the smaller Prime Rib dinner, as I knew that was readilly available. The no-flavor prime rib was just as other meals, mediocre 'at best'. The owner whom priced out our meal had the nerve to charge me for the Lamb special $$$$ vs the small prime rib dinner. One person of our 5 party had a "good meal". After contacting the owner days later explaing our experience and asking only to be compensated for the outragious "OVER CHARGED" prices compared to the on-line menu, he basically refused and offered a measly $25.00 certificate for a future visit. I explained that we were there on vacation from 6 hours away and that offer was unacceptable. He refused any other considerations, as expected. Also, he added that he was unable to do anything about the outdated menu found on-line, under their own name, not some delivery website. He was obviously, not 'willing' to remove it from the internet. Stay away from this...

Unforgettable Supper Club Extravaganza! 5 Stars is NOT enough!!! Wow, where do I even begin? My recent experience at Tally Ho Supper Club was nothing short of extraordinary, earning it a well-deserved 5 stars! The culinary journey was an absolute masterpiece. Each course was a symphony of flavors, a dance of textures, and a work of art on the plate. It was evident that the chefs poured their hearts into creating dishes that not only delighted the taste buds but also sparked conversations around the table. What truly set this supper club apart was the warm and engaging staff....especially our server, Richie. His knowledge of the menu, paired with his genuine passion for ensuring every guest felt welcome and pampered, created an atmosphere that was both relaxed and refined. He was our evening's entertainment was the cherry on top of an already splendid night. In summary, this supper club experience was an absolute triumph. It's rare to find an event that combines exquisite cuisine, impeccable service, enchanting entertainment, and a genuine sense of community. I left with a heart full of joy, a belly full of delectable dishes, and memories that will undoubtedly stay with me for a lifetime. If you're seeking a truly extraordinary dining experience that transcends the ordinary, look no further – this supper club is an absolute must! Bravo to the entire team for orchestrating an evening that was nothing short of magical. I eagerly await the opportunity to relive this enchanting journey on...