Classic Cafe — Restaurant in Town of Starkey

Went with my boyfriend to get late lunch. I ordered a burger and he got scrambled eggs. As soon as the food came out I noticed a large curly black hair on top of the burger. I pointed it out to the waitress and she grabbed it out of my food with her bare hands and asked if I needed a new sandwich. I said yes and as she took my plate back to the kitchen I notice another long hair cooked into my boyfriend's scrambled eggs. When she came back she set my plate down and immediately walked away, so we called for her to show her the eggs. She took his plate back to the kitchen and made him new eggs. Didn't check on us once, never refilled our drinks and didn't bring me the condiments I asked for. I didn't end up eating the burger as I lost my appetite but my boyfriend ate his eggs. While my boyfriend was eating another customer was complaining about a sticky table and that they had placed their arms in something sticky, and had their entire meal comped. When we went to counter to pay I asked her to take my meal off as I didn't eat it and she said "well what was wrong with it." Ended up paying 9$ for a small plate of scrambled eggs and two iced teas. Incredibly unimpressed with how the situation was handled. The food here is usually pretty good but was so dissatisfied and disappointed that I probably won't be returning...

I have very fond memories of growing up and coming here for hot chocolate with the whipped topping, but unfortunately this was a not so fond memory. My group of four arrived when the cafe only had one other table and were greeted by the owner who offered us a seat. After being seated we waited an additional 10 minutes before being acknowledged again as two other tables came in (regulars) and were waited on before us, however, we continued to place our orders. It took an additional 10 minutes to get our drinks and we got like 2 sips before our food came out. When our food arrived we explained that I was missing a sausage patty from my plate and the waitress returned quickly with a sausage patty. As I ate my food I took one bite from that sausage patty just to realize that it was not done. I finished eating and explained to the owner I was not looking for a refund but wanted her to know for future customers and I wasn’t rude about it. However my mother paid the bill but before she did she realized the prices were different from the menu. I would recommend the hot chocolate to anyone especially on a cold day, but unfortunately I would not...

If you're anywhere near Dundee, New York, and find yourself hungry, do yourself a favor and stop in at the Classic Café. My wife and I recently discovered this cozy spot and were thoroughly impressed. We shared a Reuben sandwich that arrived perfectly grilled on hearty pumpernickel rye—every bite was a delicious balance of savory corned beef, tangy sauerkraut, melty Swiss, and just the right touch of dressing. It was classic comfort food, elevated.

As a coffee enthusiast, I’m picky—but the coffee here was outstanding. Rich, aromatic, and freshly brewed, it paired wonderfully with our lunch and gave the meal that warm, satisfying finish.

The atmosphere is welcoming, the service friendly, and the food prepared with care. Whether you're just passing through or a local looking for a reliable bite, the Classic Café will not disappoint. We'll...