Dom's Pizza Subs & Wings — Restaurant in Town of Stillwater

Irks me to do this, only because I do enjoy their food majority of the time. Delivery is usually spot on and I tip 10$ every time because good service deserves a good tip. I ordered a 10 cut with an order of wings and the delivery driver arrived with the incorrect food. Said he had to go back to shop to get it. I called in and was put on hold and waited 10 minutes just for their machine to hang up. Called back and the manager answered. Explained what happened and he said the driver gave my food to the wrong person. Granted I already handed him the 10$ tip prior when he had the wrong food, I said just come back in a friendly manner. The manager offered me a 10$ credit on my next order. When my food actually arrived 2 hours after originally ordering the pizza was over cooked and burnt. I was defeated and wanted to call back but I really don’t like complaining. A 10$ credit was a slap in the face. The delivery driver didn’t even offer their 10$ tip back for his mistake and all in all left a bad taste in my mouth including the burnt...

If you live in mechanicville and know good pizza, you're going to have to leave mechanicville to get it and Doms is the closest place. The sauce is great. Nice and garlicky, generous with the toppings, nice slightly sweet crust and the pie is just always cooked perfectly. If I had one gripe it would simply be that they're a bit out of my price range without coupon, but you get what you pay for. I'd rather pay more for a Doms pie than eat a medicine tasting pizza from M'ville House of Grease for free anyday.

For a region with so many Italians and Greeks, I dont know how Doms can be the only place for miles that you'll get a decent pie everytime. Cheers and happy holidays

Edit: if you're familiar with italian american places in the capital region, the closest thing I can compare Doms to is Angelina's over in Queensbury, but Doms pies have less oil, in my opinion, and the subs at Doms seem to be higher quality with more...

My three star rating does not have any reflection on the food. The food is normally very good but the prices have gone sky high. I normally order from my favorite local pizza shop (8-cut, 2 toppings pizza, $14.45). Their pizza is amazing but their hours are very screwy. At Dom's, the same pizza is just shy of $22. That's a significant price difference. I only occasionally order from Dom's now because of the pricing. I will have to be really really craving a pizza to order from Dom's again when my regular place is closed. At this rate, they are going to price themselves out of business. Edit in response to owner's response: Ingredients must be flown in from Italy then. I don't see a quality difference between yours and my favorite local shop. Sorry that I created defensiveness on your part but no pizza is worth an extra $8 especially when it's hit or...