Candyman Pizza — Restaurant in Town of Tonawanda

I’m not from Buffalo and was looking for a good place to order pizza late Saturday night. I saw the high rating and the pictures looked good @ Candyman’s Pizza, so I called and ordered a large extra cheese pizza. I was asked a name for the order and told 25 minutes. Upon arrival, there was no visible place named Candyman’s Pizza. After much confusion and entrance to the wrong place that had pizza on their sign, we found a door that said Candyman’s. Upon entrance to a bar area, we were sent to the connecting building through another door and wound up in an even darker and louder bar. After waiting awhile to find someone free, we said we were there to pick up a pizza. We were handed a tiny little box while my debit card was being charged and I was thoroughly confused about the size of the box. My boyfriend opened it up and there are no words to describe how much the little round thing inside did NOT in any way resemble a large, sauce covered, extra cheesey, gooey, hot, delicious pizza that I believed I had ordered. When my boyfriend pointed it out to the cashier, her response was, it’s a Quatro Formaggio wood-fired pizza and we only have one size. That was news to me and should have been relayed to me at the time of my order. I tried the tiny, lifeless, conglomeration of cold cheese and it went in the trash. Whatever it was, it wasn’t pizza. Never...

The food at Candman Pizza is great as always, everything we ordered was fresh and flavorful. However, the service this time was a bit off. When we asked for our wings well done, the server didn’t mention that the special wings were baked, so they came out undercooked. She also upcharged us for extra blue cheese, not realizing it already came with the wings. There were a few other small things, like not checking on us after our drinks and food arrived and trying to ring us up for a second order of wings while leaving the undercooked ones. That said, her personality was kind and polite. With a bit more training, the service could easily match the quality...

I just happened to be in western New York on vacation. So I asked Google for the best pizza in New York. Candyman pizza came up and it didn't disappoint! The pizza candyman style was the most awesome pizza I've ever had the pleasure to taste. The crust and dough were perfect! The taste....OMG!! The honey and pepper drizzle put this pizza on a whole different level. They also had the best wings! Perfect combination of savory flavor and crunch! Please do yourself a favor and order you a pie candyman style with their barbecue wings! You'll be glad you did! We need one of these places in...