Keystone Hoagies — Restaurant in Town of Tuxedo

I just happened to be hungry and in the area so I searched “food” and Keystone Hoagies was the first thing to pop up. I drove over expecting a small sandwich shop but to my surprise, there’s also a bakery here.

From the moment I walked in, the service was exceptional and the restaurant has a warm atmosphere.

Second surprise came when I ordered the shrimp Po boy expecting a small sandwich, the sandwich was huge and delicious! Also ordered a ginger limeade and a snickerdoodle cookie. 10/10 will be back and would recommend. I’m so happy I was hungry in the area and happy that I decided to give this...

So I’ve been here before and had a veggie Duffy who was terrific but no longer on the menu came back had the shrimp po boy. My husband had the cheesesteak, and both were disgusting; that cheesesteak had ZERO flavors. I mean, Zero, he took one bite and left the whole hero there. I took two bites of my shrimp and left it, and I was so upset because I hate to throw away food. I’ve been back since then and kept getting disappointed, so, unfortunately, I will never go back. My husband, on the other, had...

Every sandwich I have tried has been a joy to eat.  Had a causal afternoon date here and sat outside.  I had the Polish Hammer (Kielbasa, Pierogis, Kraut, Onions and Mustard) , She had the CAB Roast Beef (Angus beef, Roasted garlic spread, Roasted red peppers).  The sandwiches were layered with flavor, with each bite you tasted the fresh ingredients and love that went into the meal.  Can’t get enough of the hand cut fries.   It’s a pleasure...