Between the Lakes BBQ — Restaurant in Town of Varick

Probably the best and most underrated BBQ ive ever had. Way less busy than expected, food came out quick and hot. Prices were very reasonable, almost underpriced in my opinion. Got the shotgun shells, brisket, and ribs. Absolutely delicious, smokey, and hot. The mac, potatoes and cornbread were equally delicious. Coleslaw lacked a bit of flavor but nothing major, could have been the top of the barrel. Overall a great experience with amazing food, service, and a beautiful view...

Talk about an absolutely delicious BBQ with “you’re taking some home for lunch tomorrow” portions. We had the brisket, and let me tell you, it was the most tender, smokey, slab of deliciousness this side of the Mississippi!! Definitely have a repeat customer. They also have a dock on the west side of Cayuga if you want to pull up by boat. Just a quick walk across the street and you’ll be...

I recently hired Between the Lakes BBQ to cater a Summer party at my home and everything was exceptional. The communication was easy, the cost was more than fair, and the food was sooooo good! A few people didn’t make it, leaving me with leftovers, and I am 0% sad about it!! Will be using again...