Papa Leo's Pizzeria — Restaurant in Town of Wheatfield

The only reason I am giving 2 stars is because the employee that took my order was pleasant and friendly, otherwise I would have just given 1 star.... Where do I start? We ordered the 20 wing and large pizza combo that also comes with breadsticks. The breadsticks were flavorless and undercooked served with a side of sauce that taste like its straight from a can. The wings were cooked nicely and pretty big, but the medium sauce was barely existent and not even mild in flavor. The pizza.... omg.... the worst ever! I didn't even finish once slice. The cheese tasted like dirty dish water, the sauce.... I'm not sure if we were lucky to not get any or what. If it's the same sauce they use to dip the breadsticks I consider that a win! The crust is either bought pre made or the frozen variety that comes premade. Flavorless, tough and chewy... not exactly what we look for in WNY where there's 100 pizza places within 25 miles. All this and on top of it they give you one of those prepackaged bags of miniature carrots, no celery and 1 prepackaged blue cheese for 20 wings. I called to see how many blue cheese you get with an order of 10 wings.... 1. Then why would they think 1 blue cheese is adequate for 20!?!? I feel ripped off right now. Never again! You should be ashamed of yourselves honestly.

*upon further consideration, I've changed my mind. 1 star is honestly all you deserve. The guy that took my order is the only thing that saved you from zero. There is probably a good reason why your establishment only had a 3.8 already. I'll start reading the reviews more carefully...

We are pretty regular customers living so close and that’s about to change. I called when they opened this morning, ordered med pizza with pepperoni and mushrooms and 10 mild wings and requested delivery at 5 pm like 6 hours from the time I ordered.. Order showed up 40 minutes late, driver claimed it was still hot because it was sitting on top of their oven. He was wrong, wings were cold and greasy because they were swimming in sauce and pizza was barely warm. I was billed for a bachelor pack which I did not order but you don’t see the receipt until after you’ve paid if you’re paying by card. I wasn’t expecting to see a container with breadsticks (part of a bachelor pack order) and I have an old menu so I’m not sure of the difference between what I actually ordered and what I was billed for, but the breadsticks have been tried before and not liked so todays were tossed without opening since they were not ordered. I think it’s a shame that this place seems to be losing its good food, good service reputation. Probably not using...

if I could I would give them 0 wife ordered subs wheatfield location they told her cant put oil on the side for the sub the menu says pizza logs shaken in hot sauce was option on menu kid said they don't do that she went picked food up kids are all in kitchen talking and joking made her wait almost 5 minutes she said til they acknowledged her she showed the menu to kid waiting on her about pizza logs shaken in medium sauce they laughed said oh ya I guess we do that and then he said to other kid I guess we give blue cheese for buffalo chicken logs also and they both laughed .food got home sausage was laying on top of sub roll not in it was suppose to be well done not even brown or warm about a tablespoon of steak on sub no oil at all rolls not toasted. literally 4 onion rings in order. chicken fingers had no sauce cold and roll not toasted food was disgusting we've ordered their before with mixup tried again...