The other guy pizza — Restaurant in Trenton Township

The Other Guy Pizza is close to our place in Sunbury and this is the first time having it. Ordered the meat lovers pizza and it was done and ready on time (about 25 minutes) . The toppings and sauce had an excellent taste and the amount of toppings was just right. The crust was also very good and I'd rank that part higher but we tend to like Neapolitan style crust that places like Paulie Gees and Sextons have but for a non-Neapolitan style, this crust was very good and I felt it was a better crust than a number of places that have a "Columbus style" pizza crust. Excellent pizza and not quite 5 stars for us only because our personal preference in crust. Don't take that to mean , we didn't like the crust , just like a Neapolitan style crust a bit better. Appreciate having a privately owned pizza place like this so close to home...We will...

Simply amazing edge to edge pizza!

Veteran owned and operated, this quaint little pizza restaurant is located in what seems "The middle of nowhere". Just north of New Albany, Ohio approximately 12-14 minutes, this little place is worth the drive! With every visit, the dough pizza dough has been soft, yet cooked all of the way through, with just a light crunch to gove it the correct texture, the cheese is fully melted and cooked but is not burned, the toppings are fresh and the sauce is thick and robust; seems to be made from scratch. The owner is always friendly, has a great attitude and goes out of his way to make sure every customer has a great experience. This little place gives me the pleasure of leaving 5 stars with positive feedback and as long as this little shop is in business, I will...

First time ordering from here. Best: friendly service; great chat with the owners. Happy I could support a local business that's been open for 3 years!

Great: meatball sub; I think the meatballs are prepared in-house; they are very flavorful. Pizza was delicious; half deluxe (shaved meatballs in top!) + half vegetarian (very tasty with good assortment of veggies). Offers pie slices or square slices.

Good: garlic knots were good; better than Domino's. Cookie from local baker was big and crumbly.

My new go-to place for New York style pizza and amazingly flavorful...