Hall's Ice Cream — Restaurant in Tuscarora Township

I would love to give this quaint little ice cream shop 5 stars. The ice cream was delicious, don't get me wrong, but their large that costs well around the $10 mark is a bit overpriced in my opinion. Seriously, their large is more like a medium at most other places and the sundae didn't even reach the top of my cup.

Their large milkshakes are around the $10 mark as well and that is double what we typically we pay anywhere else.

So, bottom line, if you're having a craving for ice cream, don't waste your time searching this place out unless you want to spend a little over the $30 mark for three products.

This is not the place that I remember from my younger years,...

Hall's Ice Cream has been in business for 62 years, manufacturing and retailing rich creamy delicious ice cream. Lite, Premium (14% butterfat), honey, and no-sugar-added flavors are available. Their no-frills shop in Millerstown (just across the bridge from downtown) has all flavors of ice cream available, as well as cheese, meats, and other snack, its open Fri 5p-9p, Saturday 4pm-9pm and Sun 2p-9pm. On our visit we had a strawberry sundae (2.95), chocolate yogurt milkshake (2.50) and a chocolate cone (2.40). For Sale at your local Karns, Hilcher's, BG's or Mutzbaugh's Markets. Be sure to check it out if you're ever...

I was really disappointed. I brought home a pint. The coffee pint I bought was icy and not real creamy. Not a lot of coffee flavor. I also got a honey pecan with peanut butter sundae and was not impressed with that flavor nor did i get much peanut butter topping. I was very disappointed. I find supermarket brands better. I am sorry to say this but need to let the...