Shep’s Pizza & Subs — Restaurant in West Virginia

This review is meant to be helpful not hurtful. This is how I feel: The pizza reminds me of something that you would get from the carnival. Cardboard like crust with an overly sweet sauce. Toppings are completely fine as well as the cheese. They use real strips of bacon. My main problem is that it wasn’t worth the $33 for one pizza! I’ve never paid that for one pizza let alone a school cafeteria style pizza. I’m hoping that the next time I try it that I feel...

The steak sub is cheesy and delicious, with the right amount of peppers, tomatoes, and seasoned lettuce. The bun is soft and not dry. The portion is quite large. All in all, the sub is so good it rivals those of another famous local sub shop in nearby Cumberland, MD, that starts with a "D." The staff is really...

Shep’s has the best speciality pizzas in the area! It’s a great hidden gem! They load the speciality pizza with tons of delicious toppings and it’s excellent. The buffalo pizza and Taco pizza is our favorites!! They also have awesome wedgies. Seriously such an excellent place!! Extremely friendly workers...