HTML SitemapExplore
logo
Find Things to DoFind The Best Restaurants

Bonanza — Restaurant in White Deer Township

Name
Bonanza
Description
Old West-themed chain known for its steaks, chicken & all-you-can-eat buffet.
Nearby attractions
Nearby restaurants
Short Stop New Columbia / Chester's Chicken
600 New Columbia Rd, New Columbia, PA 17856
Nearby hotels
Quality Inn New Columbia-Lewisburg
330 Commerce Park Dr, New Columbia, PA 17856
Holiday Inn Express Lewisburg/New Columbia by IHG
160 Commerce Park Dr, New Columbia, PA 17856
Related posts
Keywords
Bonanza tourism.Bonanza hotels.Bonanza bed and breakfast. flights to Bonanza.Bonanza attractions.Bonanza restaurants.Bonanza travel.Bonanza travel guide.Bonanza travel blog.Bonanza pictures.Bonanza photos.Bonanza travel tips.Bonanza maps.Bonanza things to do.
Bonanza things to do, attractions, restaurants, events info and trip planning
Bonanza
United StatesPennsylvaniaWhite Deer TownshipBonanza

Basic Info

Bonanza

300 Commerce Park Dr, New Columbia, PA 17856
3.8(793)
order
order
Order
delivery
Save
spot

Ratings & Description

Info

Old West-themed chain known for its steaks, chicken & all-you-can-eat buffet.

attractions: , restaurants: Short Stop New Columbia / Chester's Chicken
logoLearn more insights from Wanderboat AI.
Phone
(570) 568-1200

Plan your stay

hotel
Pet-friendly Hotels in White Deer Township
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
Affordable Hotels in White Deer Township
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
The Coolest Hotels You Haven't Heard Of (Yet)
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
Trending Stays Worth the Hype in White Deer Township
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Featured dishes

View full menu
dish
Mashed Potato & Gravy
dish
Signature Sirloin Tips
dish
Grilled Chicken
dish
Signature Breaded Bone-In Chicken Wings

Reviews

Things to do nearby

Home School Meet & Greet
Home School Meet & Greet
Fri, Dec 12 • 8:30 AM
104 West 4th Street, Williamsport, PA 17701
View details
33 Years Around the Sun: BEarthday & Graduation Celebration
33 Years Around the Sun: BEarthday & Graduation Celebration
Fri, Dec 12 • 6:30 PM
126 South Front Street, Milton, PA 17847
View details
Kiwanis Club of Williamsport: Breakfast with Santa
Kiwanis Club of Williamsport: Breakfast with Santa
Sat, Dec 13 • 8:00 AM
601 Market Street, Williamsport, PA 17701
View details

Nearby restaurants of Bonanza

Short Stop New Columbia / Chester's Chicken

Short Stop New Columbia / Chester's Chicken

Short Stop New Columbia / Chester's Chicken

4.4

(136)

Click for details
Get the Appoverlay
Get the AppOne tap to find yournext favorite spots!
Wanderboat LogoWanderboat

Your everyday Al companion for getaway ideas

CompanyAbout Us
InformationAI Trip PlannerSitemap
SocialXInstagramTiktokLinkedin
LegalTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy

Get the app

© 2025 Wanderboat. All rights reserved.
logo

Reviews of Bonanza

3.8
(793)
avatar
1.0
4y

Went there for Mothers Day 5/9/2021 arrived around 4:03pm there was a line outside the door. We got in line n as we was able to get into the building the line started to take forever. The manager never once told the customers on what was going on here the credit card machine went down # of times n she never once said anything to the customers to let them know. I had a two year old with me holding her the whole time cause it was like we was in a can of sardines people shoulder to shoulder. There was other people with kids there as well and Am sure they was feeling the same way I was. It took forever to get through the line was like 1 hr 45 mins or better without the manager telling us what was going on and not telling us that the credit card machine was down. Never once apologized for the wait or the issues that seem to be taken place. Then for them to up their prices on Mothers Day like really?? WHY?? Then to only be able to order from a list of items that they are cooking. I got the steak shrimp baked potato with butter and extra butter. Steak was well done like I asked but was dry tasteless like there was no seasonings at all on my steak. My husband got a steak n chicken with baked potato sour cream n butter. He was not happy at all with the serves or the food. Mostly it being mothers day n my steak being the way that it was n they forgot the butter for his potato n we both got the salad bar. Spend over $50 to be in line that long for a manager who didnt seem to care or what to communicate with her customers. I dont like to complain but I have to say we was very unhappy with everything that took place. I believe the manager should have spoken up to let customers know what was going on....

   Read more
avatar
2.0
4y

Bonanza steak house The salad bar: had many great selections!!! Everything looked fresh and tasted fresh! The soup: was amazing too and was on point!! The steam table: only items I felt was good was: Glazed meatloaf The chicken fingers Orange chicken Buttered cabbage Everything else was not fully cooked. The fried chicken was raw in the center and smelled bad like it's been under someone's armpit!.. The mashed potatoes and stuffing was so dry ..no hope in its flavor it was dry and nasty.. the gravy was coagulated. The corn was bland, the string beans casserole was mushy and just awful.. the sweet potato were burned. Everything looked just awful..presentation!! The desert bar.. what a mess!! The ice cream bar ..what the Hell!! There are so many slobes that come to a restaurant and make a big mess.. it's a shame you have to walk into sprinkles and some people have no control over thier kids! They allow them to act like brats out of a friggin barn.. I felt I was dinning with barn animals.. in fact I believe barn animals would have better manners then some of these pigs. I really feel bad for the staff.. I know they don't get paid enough to put up with feeding time at the ZOO in New Columbia! But to say this I know Bonanza is short handed..they do need help. The cakes looked very good btw.. I would of gotten a piece. But people made my stomach turn.. I just cannot believe people act the way they do.. no...

   Read more
avatar
2.0
7y

Served romaine lettuce in salad during the e-coli outbreak and voluntary recall of romaine (server did replace salad with one without the romaine when informed).

Food was ok, simple basic but not excellent. Serving staff excellent - kind to customers, pleasant demeaner.

There was some confusion between staff and management over policies for additional items and discounts not listed on the menu. As this was our first time at this restaurant, this made it harder to select a combination of food for our group.

After we worked out an order with the staff, the general manager came over and provided a very strict interpretation of the policies with a goal of charging us an extra five dollars on 35 dollars of food. We ended up purchasing less food as a result.

Her demeaneer and managing style was confrontational and inflexible. She was very present and active in the restaurant. Her oversight made eating there unpleasant. She angrily confronted us implying theft and charged us an exra dollar for a tiny brownie that a staff member said we could take for my son (after the salad fiasco) (we paid the dollar).

What's frustrating is that all this could have been avoided at the start and end if she had talked to the staff before confronting us and offered solutions instead of...

   Read more
Page 1 of 7
Previous
Next

Posts

Vincent CanzoneriVincent Canzoneri
Came here while driving through due to the good ratings. Was highly disappointed. Ordered a porter house (ny strip on one side, fillet on the other), when the steak came out was completely missing the fillet side. Spoke with the manager who stated they come like that from the distributor. So, they don’t sell porter house steak, they sell a strip at the price of a porter house. Ok, not their fault, but then I cut into the steak (medium rare), it was barely rare at best. Cold grey center with lots of muscle fibers that the steak knife wouldn’t cut through. Then the buffet left much to be desired. The salad and soup bar was good. The hot foods seemed to be there for hours they looked like. The Mac and cheese for my son was one solid piece. The chicken nuggets were hard to cut or bite through. And the cakes had sat so long, the cake batter was hard and crunchy. Overall very poor experience. Staff was nice. But cooks are not cooking appropriately and the GM should be ordering better steaks. The steak was bottom of the barrel before they cooked it. 2 stars because service was nice and the salad and soup bar were nice.
Travis DelcampTravis Delcamp
Clean place with some very friendly staff. One star off excessive coughing into her hand without washing them. Overall vibe bothered me. Not because it was meh, but because it was a lie. It had all this about quality and freshness, but the buffet was anything but. It was all frozen. The catfish I had could qualify as one of the single worst things I have ever eaten. Everything else tasted either really off or really dry. The hush puppies they had were the best thing I ate, and they were a little dry. Overall I would not go here. Was hoping it was as good as I remembered it as a kid, but boy did I grow up. Save your money and eat frozen food from the grocery store and stay home instead…
Donnie RDonnie R
My girlfriend and I tried it for the very first time and we were impressed. It's confusing when you first go in because you pay first at the counter regardless of if you're getting the buffet or not. We got the buffet and everything was very good. Lots of options and variety. We went for dinner on a Wednesday and it was packed. The staff seemed friendly and refilled the food in a timely manner. I would definitely go back again, and will be back to try the breakfast buffet. There's a lot of negative reviews for this place but I would say give this place a try because there's a lot of ignorant people that just want to complain.
See more posts
See more posts
hotel
Find your stay

Pet-friendly Hotels in White Deer Township

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Came here while driving through due to the good ratings. Was highly disappointed. Ordered a porter house (ny strip on one side, fillet on the other), when the steak came out was completely missing the fillet side. Spoke with the manager who stated they come like that from the distributor. So, they don’t sell porter house steak, they sell a strip at the price of a porter house. Ok, not their fault, but then I cut into the steak (medium rare), it was barely rare at best. Cold grey center with lots of muscle fibers that the steak knife wouldn’t cut through. Then the buffet left much to be desired. The salad and soup bar was good. The hot foods seemed to be there for hours they looked like. The Mac and cheese for my son was one solid piece. The chicken nuggets were hard to cut or bite through. And the cakes had sat so long, the cake batter was hard and crunchy. Overall very poor experience. Staff was nice. But cooks are not cooking appropriately and the GM should be ordering better steaks. The steak was bottom of the barrel before they cooked it. 2 stars because service was nice and the salad and soup bar were nice.
Vincent Canzoneri

Vincent Canzoneri

hotel
Find your stay

Affordable Hotels in White Deer Township

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Get the Appoverlay
Get the AppOne tap to find yournext favorite spots!
Clean place with some very friendly staff. One star off excessive coughing into her hand without washing them. Overall vibe bothered me. Not because it was meh, but because it was a lie. It had all this about quality and freshness, but the buffet was anything but. It was all frozen. The catfish I had could qualify as one of the single worst things I have ever eaten. Everything else tasted either really off or really dry. The hush puppies they had were the best thing I ate, and they were a little dry. Overall I would not go here. Was hoping it was as good as I remembered it as a kid, but boy did I grow up. Save your money and eat frozen food from the grocery store and stay home instead…
Travis Delcamp

Travis Delcamp

hotel
Find your stay

The Coolest Hotels You Haven't Heard Of (Yet)

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

hotel
Find your stay

Trending Stays Worth the Hype in White Deer Township

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

My girlfriend and I tried it for the very first time and we were impressed. It's confusing when you first go in because you pay first at the counter regardless of if you're getting the buffet or not. We got the buffet and everything was very good. Lots of options and variety. We went for dinner on a Wednesday and it was packed. The staff seemed friendly and refilled the food in a timely manner. I would definitely go back again, and will be back to try the breakfast buffet. There's a lot of negative reviews for this place but I would say give this place a try because there's a lot of ignorant people that just want to complain.
Donnie R

Donnie R

See more posts
See more posts