Hunters Pub and Steakhouse — Restaurant in Whitesville

Well to being with we get there at 4:25 they open at 5:00 I was third in line with a party of 9 for my daughter’s birthday (3 from the group wasn’t there yet they got lost) they open at 5:00 we go in and sit down get our drinks and the server ask us “where is the location of the rest or the party” “do we know what they will be eating and drinking” I completely understand wanting to turn the table as quick as possible but not even two min later I’m assuming she was the manager from watching her run the business wile eating come over and ask “how long before the rest of your group gets here” needless to say they was in the parking lot by then trying to fight their way to the door no later than 5:20 max. To me it was very unprofessional to be asked not 1 time but 2 times within 5 minutes where the rest of the party was like I was being rushed to make them get there. I understand that turning tables to make money is the way they make their living because iv been in the restaurant business since 2009 they lost what could of been a regular customer and a great tipper because of wanting to ask where the rest of the party was and making me feel like I was being rushed to get them there. Maybe it was just a bad day for them or maybe it happens all the time but either way it was very unprofessional I waited a couple of days to post the review because I know how bad it could hurt small business with bad reviews but I just couldn’t get past it so with that being said y’all make your own Decision as to if you want to eat here but for me and my daughter well I guess you can figure that one out. And it’s sad because we like small business to spend our money at and that’s what I’m teaching my child is to support small business but not the ones who don’t care about...

First time here, told by someone about it and the place didn't disappoint! Whole in the wall steakhouse for sure! Open at 5, get there at 5 or after 7, if not, your gonna wait, not a ton of seating and it's tight in there! Waited 20 mins to sit, from sitting to getting our meal was 1hr but again they were packed at that time. Had jalapeno poppers appetizer, 2 waters, 1 mountain dew (yes they serve Pepsi products, so hard to find around here and I was happy, sorry coke fans LOL) Ribeye with fries and mixed onions and mushrooms, NY strip with loaded potatoe and side salad. Ghirardelli peanut butter pie X2...$110. This is a steakhouse, so you come for the steak and it was well worth it, delicious and cooked correctly! Would have liked a little more fries with the plate and potato was lukewarm. Jalapeno poppers are delicious...be careful, hot and cheese squirts out and will burn your mouth, I'm sure we have all been there lol. Side salad only comes with tomato and cucumber, added cheese and bacon. Chocolate peanut butter pie is so so good, only thing I'll say is although the crust is thin, it tastes really weird, almost like a stale or freezer burn taste, need to fix that. Of note, they have fried lobster tail, not on the menu...we didn't know but will definitely ask for it next time! Brittany our server was also really nice and even though it was busy, she was accessible. We will...

Mark your staff has not allowed customers to play the jukebox because the switch is off. this restaurant just lost the best cook within a hundred miles of Columbus. His name is Gene. I've only met him once but everything he cooked was five star excellent and now he's gone. The slop I ate tonight was the worst spaghetti sauce I've seen anywhere bar none. It's all you can eat and I ate one bowl and left that's all I could stomach. I will never never never come back to this restaurant until they get a real cook named Gene. Mr Jones you might as well close the restaurant permanently because when it spreads that Gene is no longer there and the food taste beyond horrible you'll have to close it anyway. I don't know what you were paying him but you should have tripled his salary many years ago and now you've lost the best cook within a hundred miles of your restaurant. I drove 30 minutes from Columbus just to eat here but not anymore. I've eaten at some of your other restaurants where the food is average but this was the only restaurant you had were the food was excellent when you had your cook. I guess you just like average or less. Don't call us cuz we surely won't be calling you I had over 100,000 reviews from all the restaurants I eat at last month and yours was At the top of the list # 1 in the top 100 for the best restaurant within a hundred miles of Columbus and now You're not Even...