Nana's Attic — Attraction in Town of Middletown

I recently visited Nana's Attic in Arkville, NY, and it felt like stepping into a time machine. I bought some baseball cards from 1987, 1988, and 1989, and seeing the all-stars of my past almost brought me to tears. The thrill of pulling out those familiar faces and even finding that hard-as-a-rock stick of gum in the packs was an incredible nostalgic trip.

Nana's Attic isn't just another antique shop – it's a place where memories come alive. They have unique signs specific to the Catskills region and the larger American experience, which add a special touch. The shop is filled with funny and nostalgic gifts that make you smile and reminisce.

The staff is super friendly and knowledgeable, making the experience even more special. Whether you're a serious collector or just someone looking for a unique and nostalgic find, this place has something for everyone.

I had an amazing time and can't wait to go back. If you ever find yourself in Arkville, make sure to stop by Nana's Attic. You won't be...

I realize I’ve never written a review in the 6-7 (I think…?) years of weekend and seasonal getaways with my friends. Without fail, we always come to check out what has come in store at Nana’s Attic.

No- it’s not your average “thrift store”… it’s much better and a break from the average. (albeit, clothes and furniture is not my style of thrifting anyways… nor was I into thrifting)

I never cease to get lost in this deceivingly small building and find unique, witchy, magical, strange, unusual, and eclectic items. Most of us in my group walk out with something without fail and return without fail.

The owners are absolutely lovely and run the place like clockwork. Never a dull conversation and learn more about the place and its plethora of treasures.

If you haven’t stopped by… it’s really worth the trip if you find yourself...

Hartsdale New York is going to miss Nana's Attic. This place was an absolute treasure in this area for close to 50 years. When you needed an antique item or a trinket as a gift, this was the place to come to. I wish them the best of luck upstate New York. It's funny that the building that they are going into is almost exactly the same as the one they're in. I sent them a lot of business and did some business with them over the years. I highly recommend taking a trip to get what you need or local residents upstate take advantage of what they have to offer. They are truly wonderful people. It is not going to be easy passing by that empty building on Central Avenue every day but let's wish them the best of luck where they are now....