Winney Farm Store — Local services in Bainbridge Island

They have a nice selection. But I only recommend patronizing this store if you have time and money to burn. I’m all for sustainable, all natural, free range, etc, but I need a balance between convenience and fidelity. The bagel was ok. But I can feed a family of four a nice salmon dinner for what they wanted to charge for a bagel with lox and cream cheese. The cashier was unpleasant, and it took them ten minutes to toast a bagel and put it in a box with a tub of cream cheese. I had to ask for a knife. I’m probably not going back. If they have customers that will spend $17 on a bagel (the same that they charge for a whole rotisserie chicken), I’m impressed. But some people work...

My SO says it’s the best pastrami sandwich he’s had. I got the seasonal veggie and it was incredibly delicious. It smelled so good when the cashier handed it to me we couldn’t wait to get home to eat it so we just sat outside, haha. I’ve already ordered it 2x in one week. I do wish they added one more vegetarian sandwich for variety but I do love the one they...

Spicy pork sandwich is delicious - the perfect size, level of spiciness, and perfect amount of juiciness. The meat was cooked to perfection, I’m definitely coming back. The market also has bagels that are sort of small - perfect size if you don’t feel like eating a full sized bagel. They cook their own rotisserie chickens as well, which I will be trying...