⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ If pizza parties were an Olympic sport, Red Eye Pie would take the gold AND eat it. We’ve ordered from them for both of our kids’ birthday parties—first for our daughter, and then just recently for Maverick’s—and these pizza wizards absolutely delivered. This last time, we had them whip up 11 pizzas like it was no big deal (and somehow they still smiled at us), including a mango, crab, and bacon pizza that sounded like a dare… until everyone tried it and immediately questioned all their past pizza choices.
The kids inhaled it like they hadn’t eaten in three days, then argued over who got the last slice like it was a rare Pokémon card. Red Eye Pie, you’re officially part of the family now. Thanks for making party madness...
Read moreVery excited to visit and support this place! We loved the pizza. However, I got a Recker and apparently the styrofoam cup broke when they were mixing it, so they just put another cup underneath the first one. When I got down towards the bottom of the ice cream, there was a HUGE piece of styrofoam from the first broken cup :/ All the ice cream then fell down the bottom into the second cup. I have no clue why this is so common and why they don’t just remake it if they accidentally break the cup! Nobody wants to eat styrofoam, and this is a major choking hazard as well especially if kids were to eat this. I couldn’t even finish my ice cream. On a positive note, there were plenty of toppings and they were mixed...
Read moreFinally got to try Red Eye, and we loved it. We got the Hot Honey Pulled Pork pizza, a half cheese and half pepperoni pizza, as well as some Wilde Bread. The pulled pork pizza was really good, the hot honey wasn't very spicy and tasted really good with the pork. The Wilde Bread was really good but my favorite was the pepperoni. It was sliced thick and had a great flavor. The edges of the thin crust got nice and crispy. We usually go out to Porky's when we stay at Maumee Bay but I think Red Eye has become...
Read more