Sugar Shark Market — Local services in Stock Island

We ‘discovered’ this new little Gem of a market while staying on Saddlebunch Feb/March 2025 (Located ~50 yards South of Baby’s Coffee, (great coffee there!), we first thought this place was called Sugar “Shack" but turns out it is "Sugar Shark" named after the owners sugar seeking pup). Amazing heritage eggs & meats, frozen quality 'heat and serve' meals, fresh organic produce, some of the most delicious hand scooped ice cream I have ever had, and an impressive and well thought out stock of food/condiments and other essentials that saved us from the 1 hour round trip to Publix on KW multiple times (not to mention saving us about $8 in gas for that round trip too!). Lara and her husband Anthony live right here in Saddlebunch Keys and have clearly put their heart and soul into building out and well stocking this market. Make it a point to check out this great little market, you...

What a wonderful and special place! Wonderful curated high-quality foods at reasonable prices! They find the best food from wherever, so imagine my surprise seeing Nueske's bacon from Wisconsin! It is worth s tip just for that, what I deem the best bacon in the world. I cannot believe the food and other items packed into this place. You can get everything you need and stuff you didn't think you needed but are happy you did! Stop by for ice cream, sandwich, or a meal kit! Outside eating, indoor bathroom, clean, cute, and fun! So happy Lara and Anthony, the great couple who own this place, have decided to breath new life into this location. They have big hearts, and philanthropic, and are great members of our community. I can't wait to go back and see...

I reached out to Sugar Shark Market to see if they could deliver treats to my mom, who was vacationing nearby, for her birthday. Not only did Lara call and message me details about what to order, she met my dad the day before Thanksgiving to deliver! She had packed up a beautiful assortment of birthday treats, with a complimentary card that she tucked in. It was so thoughtful, and she really went out of her way to make sure that she was there to meet them at a time convenient for my parents. The treats were perfect- olive oil cakes, raspberry sherbet, and ice cream cookie sandwiches that looked gourmet. I am very thankful I found Sugar Shark online- they really helped make my mom’s birthday trip memorable! Thank you...