Bellvale Market — Local services in Town of Warwick

Inconsistent hours. Numerous times I've driven there, to find a sign at the door saying they're closed for an unspecified reason.

Sandwiches are dry, flavorless, and do not use Boars Head meat, as the other review stated. Grocery store meat is a better option. The chicken cutlet I got required me to douse my own olive oil and fixings to make it even remotely edible.

The lobster bisque is a rip-off at $10 (the online menu says it's supposed to be $1 less, so don't trust that). A few small smidgens of lobster, with bisque that is overly salty and fishy-tasting.

The baked clams and chicken pot pie are good enough. I've been unimpressed with everything else.

There's one guy that's always quite pleasant, and another one that's very curt.

Basically, everything about this place is inconsistent and often disappointing, and definitely not worth the roulette wheel of "are they open or not?"...

We found this amazing little market on google maps near the AirBnb that we rented while in NY for our son's graduation. We were staying in Greenwood Lakes which is kinda far from any decent grocery stores. When I found this market place I read the reviews on google & they were all pretty decent, so I sent my husband & daughter. When they came back, all they could do was talk about the place & all the fresh meats & seafood they had. My daughter was raving about how the wife who 'especially' went in the back & got her some Italian Crema for our fruit, and then made sure to show them where the Sicilian Virgian Olive Oil was. (My husband's family is Italian) So this made him VERY happy!!! My daughter was super happy because they make their Mozzarella daily. Their prices were also very decent!!

I would suggest this market to anyone especially if you are looking for fresh...

We took a chance on Bellvale Market to cater our local wedding of about 60 and the food was very good. Knowledgeable staff assisted with quantities and menu selection. The owner delivered the food and made sure everything was good before leaving. We went with: (2) large charcuterie boards, mini arancini, and assorted artisan breads for the cocktail hour. Breads were fresh baked and boards included good assortment of fresh mozzarella and deli meats caprese salad to start. Fresh summer salad to kick off the meal chicken picatta and sausage and peppers with brocolli rabe, green beans, and fingerling potatoes as the main. Everything was fresh and there was plenty of food Would 100% recommend to others and use again...