Erika's — Restaurant in District Municipality of Muskoka

A long awaited visit that fell a bit flat

I’ve heard so many good things about Erika’s and have wanted to visit for years. today, I finally had the opportunity to stop in with my husband. The atmosphere was charming and cozy, though a bit tight on space. We still enjoyed browsing the store and taking it all in.

Unfortunately, once we reached the counter to order, we didn’t feel a particularly warm or welcoming energy from the staff, which took away from the overall experience. We ordered an iced coffee that was just okay, a breakfast bagel that was decent but not especially memorable, and a coconut butter tart. As a butter tart enthusiast, I was especially excited for that, but sadly, I didn’t even finish it. It was a letdown.

Overall, our experience was pretty mediocre. That said, we’re still open to giving Erika’s another try during lunch hours, hoping for a more positive vibe and...

To be totally honest this place I think is one of the best in Muskoka for homemade food. Everything is made from scratch right on the premises. The sandwiches are amazing. Also the pastries are to die for. It reminds me of going to grandma's house when I was a little boy. The only thing is they won't let you lick the bowl. Lol. I ordered a bacon & cheese sandwich & it was done to perfection. I also had a date square & two raisin butter tarts with a coffee. The food is totally amazing. Erika makes everything from scratch. That's what makes it so good & the best in my opinion. It's a little pricey & a bit of a drive to get their from the Huntsville area but its totally worth it. Trust me, you won't be...

We recently stayed at an Airbnb in Dwight and wanted to support their local businesses while there. We ordered in some pizza from Erika's - large Deluxe and personal cheese ... The pizza is phenomenal!! So many toppings and super cheesy! The crust is the perfect combination of thin and crispy yet soft and supportive for all the toppings. Thoroughly enjoyed it. While waiting for the pizza to be done, I browsed around their shop. I noticed a sign advertising their butter tarts. The plain were okay but the ones with raisins... Oh boy! Incredible. We also tried their Muskoka Squares - different but yummy. We will definitely be returning when we are in the area again. Expect yummy food, good prices and...