Postoffice Pizza — Restaurant in New Brunswick

We were excited to try this pizza, happy to be on the island again after 10 years. Our first interaction involved Walter rudely correcting me on his "Grand Mananer" pizza. I called it the "Grand Mariner" after reading it off a very poorly handwritten sign. Another sign pointed leftward to see the menu. I couldn't find it. Walter rudely said "it's up on the wall". We're talking way up the wall. So I ordered a Crick. Cost: over $40. But he said "we'll settle up later" which was odd. He said around 430 pizza would be ready, so we went outside to wait. I returned at the appointed hour, asked if it was ready. He pretended he couldn't hear me asking about it. I was wearing a K95 mask, as my wife is immunocompromised. Maybe he couldn't hear me well, but his body language said he was annoyed I was back so soon for the pizza. He said "it's in the oven". I left. Waited another half hour. By this time I was steamed at his obvious passive aggressive pantomime. We should have left then. But around 5 pm I went back in to get the pizza. He shows me the pizza, I pick it up, drop it on the counter in front of me, but I'm prepared to keep my mouth shut, pay and leave. Then Walter asks "Are you upset?" So I answer honestly. I say " yes, actually, I thought you were kind of rude." So he picks up the pizza, snatches it back through his little window and says "Have a good day." It's five o'clock. Walter knows the only other pizza place is closed, so we will suffer. Nope. Went up the road to High Seas takeout and got whole clams, fries and 2 desserts for less than Walter's pizza. And we were well treated. Walter's Postoffice Pizza was the most negative customer experience of our lives. We're still in shock. The passive aggressive nastiness of Walter's conduct was obvious and vindictive. We will never darken your door again, Walter. Love Grand Manan, every other experience was wonderful. Durgin-Park in Boston closed. Maybe surly service isn't so satisfying today. Have a...

Where do I begin? My mouth is still watering from this amazing pizza so excuse me while I wipe the drool from my face . Okay I am ready now. PostOffice pizza in GRAND MANAN of all places is hands down the best pizza I have ever had.

I have had pizza in many provinces across Canada and I have completely forgotten what any other pizza tastes like, after I had PostOffice Pizza. Now my expectations are so high for pizza that I will have to make more frequent trips to Grand Manan.

As I was writing this review my husband called PostOffice Pizza to tell them how amazing their pizza is and it was the best we’ve ever had. I have never seen him call any other restaurant to praise them for their amazing food.

We enjoyed The Bama and the Halifax donair pizza. These were amazing and I am especially fond of the Halifax donair pizza; this is what a dream donair pizza tastes like! The pizza’s were not greasy and plenty of good quality toppings; the dough is top notch!

Looking forward to grabbing a pizza before we leave tomorrow.

Thank you,

Katherine and Dan

PS: The meatball sub is amazing too ! I am completely stuffed and look forward to snacking on it later. Also excellent and friendly customer service, puts the extra love into the...

Pizza itself was very good. Service left much to be desired. Went twice. Second time it was busy and owner asked for a representative of each group to stay and rest go outside. My friend and I were getting pizza for two different houses paying separately. To be helpful, my friend said she would order for both of us. You pay at the end. I sat outside. No mention of limited ordering. My friend gets to window and is told only 2 orders per party. Since she ordered 1 and I wanted 2 we thought we were set. Nope. She said we were 1 party, she was running out of dough and “didn’t want to disappoint anyone in line” . Uh, we were in line. Again, not ordering 10 pizzas. When she brought out the pizzas 20 mins later (and more people joined the line) I asked her to reconsider since I was still within the 2 pizza limit and my kids were waiting at home for dinner. She again said we were 1 party and needed to let the people in line order. The line that keeps growing. After this 3 more parties go in and order pizza. I could understand if she stopped taking orders after the announcement, if she had said “only 2 pizzas per order” in the original announcement. Just bad business. So have a...