The Butchers Arms — Restaurant in Amber Valley

Coors for concern.

After reading other reviews, we ventured to this pub whilst on a weekend escape, hoping for a cozy pint. Never felt so unwelcome, it felt like we were gate crashing as one local suggested to the landlord that they should've locked the door. We brushed it off, ordered a Coors, which tasted like cider. Politely mentioned it to the landlord, who took two gulps, slammed it down, and declared it fine, polling the rest of the bar for backup. I was offered a Budweiser to replace said Coors—also cider? Landlord deemed it necessary to ask if I had brushed my teeth as there's clearly something wrong with mine and my partners taste. He then vowed to drink the pint himself (gross). Not arguing with that, it appeared he was a few pints deep already. We then headed to the Peacock up the road, where proper pints and cheery service saved the night. If you’re up for an argument with your beer, this place is your spot—just don’t expect clean lines or a warm welcome. Not sure if we caught the place on a bad day, I only wish they did bolt the door before...

We were passing this nice looking old pub after having a nice day out at Critch tram musium. We were "Greeted " with a long faced balding miserable old man who apparently knows next to nothing about customer service! When politely asking if they serve food , The abrupt answer came back .. " "Not till 5pm . I said that's ok & asked for two drinks . After a glare ,like he couldent be bothered he poured a pint of completely undrinkable ipa which I had to return . No apologies just replaced with three quarters of a pint of alternative beer & another stupid look . I then had to ask for this to be topped up !!?? Followed by another " look " . Luckly I am not a violent person . 5pm arrived & we were served by an altogether different person who was polite & pleasent. Furthermore the food was excellent & great value . What a shame the IDIOT spoils an...

All stayed nearby after a wedding. visited with 10 people including 2 small children, the service was excellent both children's meals were served just before the adults allowing them to settle before we all ate together. The pies served to each of us were all different and everyone agreed that all were excellent, I agreed to treat everyone so I was amazed how inexpensive they were. The landlord was a real character, and the pub full of old charm. Cannot praise the entire experience highly enough. I will return even though I live...