Miller & Carter Newton Mearns — Restaurant in Scotland

Tucked away in the leafy suburb of Newton Mearns, Miller & Carter has long been a stalwart of steakhouse dining, but my recent lunch visit confirmed that it’s more than just a haven for meat lovers—this is a restaurant that delivers a well-rounded and carefully curated experience from start to finish.

The meal began with a classic salt and pepper calamari starter. Calamari is a staple on many menus, yet so often executed poorly. Here, it was anything but. Lightly battered, with a crisp, golden exterior and tender, succulent calamari inside, the balance of flavors was expertly handled. A slight kick from the seasoning elevated the dish beyond the ordinary, setting the stage for what was to come.

The 7oz steak, which followed, was a masterclass in how a small cut can pack immense flavor. Cooked precisely to order, the steak arrived perfectly charred on the outside, with a juicy, tender interior. Accompanied by crisp, golden fries, a juicy grilled tomato, and the signature onion loaf—a delightful tangle of crunchy, savory ribbons—the plate was simple but exceptionally well-executed. In an era where portion control and quality can be at odds, Miller & Carter strikes a fine balance.

The dessert—a classic banoffee pie—was nothing short of indulgent, as it should be. Rich layers of banana, caramel, and cream came together in a perfect crescendo of sweetness, paired with a well-made coffee that rounded off the meal with just the right amount of bitterness.

It’s worth noting that the set lunch menu offers impressive value for money. For the quality of ingredients, precision in cooking, and overall experience, the price is more than justified.

But what truly elevated the meal was the service, with particular praise for Paul, our attentive and knowledgeable waiter. His timing was impeccable, his recommendations spot on, and his ability to anticipate our needs added a personal touch that many establishments struggle to achieve.

The surroundings, too, deserve a mention. Miller & Carter strikes a balance between elegant and approachable—stylish without pretension, a place equally suited for a casual lunch or a special occasion.

In a dining landscape where consistency can often be a rarity, Miller & Carter Newton Mearns not only meets expectations but exceeds them. A highly recommended spot for anyone seeking a well-executed, unpretentious, and thoroughly...

Just want say I thought long and hard before posting this . I have been to this restaurant several times and loved every bit of the experience from food to ambience service etc. But I booked to go on Friday 31/10/25 7 pm . When we arrived we were promptly shown to our seats and were introduced to our server for the evening . Initially everything fine took our drinks order and then came back for our food order still everything fine . Then everything changed we were left sitting for 1hr 35mins we had to ask other waiter for more drinks as we had finished off our first drinks then we waited and waited then we asked if someone was bringing our food this was 1hour after arriving . 35 mins later our appetiser arrived with one starter both cold , my starter did not come and then they got it wrong we refused the food as it was not edible . Manager came and apologised and said he would rectify this which in all fairness we said we would accept his apology and wait on food 25 mins later another appetiser appeared which we ate as by this time very hungry next came my husband starter again frozen and looked like the one we sent back . They then told me to wait another 10 mins on my food which they said was something I did not order .Took my order for starter again and then 10mind later out it came wrong starter and frozen . This was when we were done and complained and walked out . I am not saying it was the chef fault I am saying it was the server who just ignored us after taking our orders . She stood against a wall tapping away on the iPad not engaging with any customers and had the cheek to say she was sorry we were not happy and they had been getting a lot of complaints all night . Maybe if the server was doing her job we would have had a fabulous experience like before . I have raved about this restaurant to friends and family and they have all tried it . Sadly I won’t be returning this...

Having been several times over the years and had excellent service and food, my recent visit to Miller & Carter Newton Mearns was, unfortunately, one of the most disappointing dining experiences I’ve had in a long time. From start to finish, it was a series of mishaps and poor service that left me questioning the restaurant’s reputation and commitment to quality.

Their burgers are only served well done as they don't prep the mice for the burger at the restaurant, according to the food standards regulations. We weren't told this when we ordered for medium done. However, what came was overdone/dry and lukewarm chips, totally put us off the meal.

Service was a letdown. Despite asking three times for our drinks, they took an unreasonably long time to arrive. One member of our party wasn't served a side to their main course, yet it mysteriously appeared on the bill and we had to repeatedly ask for the lettuce & sauce for another dish.

As for dessert, the Banoffee pie was particularly disappointing. The quality was lamentable—far from the indulgent treat it should have been, it was more of an afterthought, clearly lacking in both flavour and freshness.

What made the experience even worse was the manager's complete disregard for our concerns. Despite the issues we raised, we were ignored and no effort was made to rectify the situation. No discount or apology was offered from him, leaving us feeling not just dissatisfied but also undervalued as customers. The only person who apologised was the waitress, she felt really bad about the whole situation.

Overall, Miller & Carter provided poor value for money. The food was formulaic and uninspired, the service poor due to understaffing, and the staff appeared under trained. I would not recommend this restaurant and will certainly not...