Yellow Frisbee Bakery/The Squatch — Restaurant in Arkansas

I recently purchased an assortment of baked goods to try out the new local bakery. I assumed it would be decent. However, I was honestly shocked at how much better than “decent” it is. Everything was fresh and clearly homemade. The scones were tender and not dry like so many. The lemon curd in the lemon bars had the perfect amount of citrus zing. The sticky bun was amazing. But the award winner, hands down, is the cinnamon rolls. We love the cinnamon rolls at War Eagle craft fair and often measure others against them. These are better. My only mistake was I bought only 2 cinnamon rolls. I should have gotten a half dozen! Absolutely fantastic. Already looking forward to...

Oatmeal Cream Pie cookies that are somehow better than the original Little Debbies? Yellow Frisbee Bakery has achieved this and you will want to bring home more than a reasonable amount. Our family ordered several dozen items for a graduation party and we, and our guests, were wowed by each item. Fruity Pebbles cake pops, Salted Caramel Chocolate Chip cookies, S’mores cookies—they were all super fresh, ready on time and the owners are very nice to work with as well. Yellow Frisbee is a sweet addition to Holiday Island and will be our go-to for high quality, freshly...

I don't quite understand the 1 star rating given above, especially without any rationale. Highly questionable. Being an actual customer, I can attest to the amazing baked goods being purveyed at Yellow Frisbee! The brownies, cookies, cinnamon rolls and other delights are the best I've run across in my 68 years. The coffee is great and the service and atmosphere impeccable. I really hope our neighbors in Eureka Springs make the short trip up to Holiday Island to make this bakery a part of their weekly, or...