Long Island New York Pizza — Restaurant in Cape Coral

We went there on Saturday afternoon 3/30. The guy making the pizza was very nice. He has a brother and he has a personality of a Long Islander. We tried to make conversation, but that lasted a long island minute. If you had been swamped with people, I could understand the standoffish attitude. There was 1 customer in the store, and they had been served. You could have excused yourself from the conversation with us. but you walked away mid conversation. As a Long Islander you made a Long Island move, and although you may have thought you were not rude. I was offended, and thought I was wrong. My friend confirmed your arrogance when we got in the car.

The slices for eating in the restaurant are very large, and you could make 2 slices out of the one. I liked the slice very much, and would like to order a pie to see if it comes in an oversized pizza box or if the pie would look like a regular pie from Suffolk county. I will order from there another day and see if things...

Yo, listen up—Long Island Brothers Pizza is the REAL DEAL. I walked in and immediately felt like I was back home. The smell? Fuggedaboutit. Crispy thin crust, perfect fold, that sauce and mozzarella that hits like a New York slice should. You can taste the attitude—in the best way possible.

These guys aren’t just tossing dough, they’re tossing memories of home. Cape Coral might be in Florida, but the flavor is straight-up NYC. You want pineapple on your pizza? Go somewhere else. You want a slice that makes you close your eyes and say “Mamma mia, that’s it!”—you come here.

Fast, friendly, and with that no-nonsense New York charm. This ain’t your average Florida pizza joint. This is Long Island Brothers—capisce?

Do yourself a favor. One bite, and you’ll be saying: “This is it right here!” Forget...

I ordered take out so I cannot really comment on atmosphere or service although the delivery was really quick so I guess I should give that a five-star. There thin crust is amazing. But, grown up in Boston and used to really good pizza it's so hard to find here in Florida I would say this is amongst the best but. The white pizza was no where near the taste of what our expect. It was good but not great. Fort Myers downtown pizza has the best white pizza you can possibly get but it's just way too far. I will order again there but I wish they would add a little more flavor to the white pizza. Next time I go order or cheese which is my second favorite pizza in see what that's like. But they're white pizza needs a little tweaking. It's pretty good...