Sicilias Pizza — Restaurant in Carneys Point Township

I had the two-slice cheese special at Sicilia’s Pizza, and it was so good! The flavor instantly took me back to being a little girl — that perfect, nostalgic New York-style bite with gooey, melted cheese and a crisp, golden crust. What really stood out is how generous they are with the cheese — you can tell they don’t skimp! Every bite was fresh, hot, and full of that comforting, homemade taste that’s hard to find these days.

I also loved that there’s a little station where you can add your own spices and toppings. It’s a nice touch that makes the experience feel even more personal. Sicilia’s definitely knows how to keep it classic while serving up quality and freshness. I’ll absolutely be back for another quick...

I've heard good things about this place but my two experiences were horrible first time my order was done wrong which was communication issue but tonight i ordered Hawaiian pizza for my girlfriend and I was completely disappointed with the food and I also ordered cheese fries and no cheese like I said first time they messed upy order and got home and had to dive back to pick up cheese and here we go once again no cheese and they closed by the time I got home so no cheese for my girlfriend's fries smh if they were more aware they would be great I'm not one to complain but I am this time. And the pizza I got literally looks like someone through hand and pineapples on top of the pizza and just put it in a box. I'll...

Disappointing!

Stopped here based on the reviews while traveling through the area and was sorely disappointed.

The order: large plain pie Sauce was watery, tasted more like marinara than pizza sauce, and there was way too much oregano. The dough was over-worked which made for a crust that was tough and chewy.

The place was freezing - I sat with my jacket wrapped around me to keep warm. Yes, it was cold out, we stopped in January, but a little heat would be nice.

The place isn't very clean and the stained ceiling tiles looks like they are going to fall out at any moment.

This establishment is not handicap accessible - especially the bathroom.

Would...