Nostalgia — Restaurant in Cromwell

I’ve had Nostalgia pizza twice now, both times take out. It’s good, tasty, fresh, quality pizza. I got the wings too and they were prime. The did three large pies and a dozen wings in under 30 minutes. That’s nice on an NFL Sunday! My only suggestion, I wish they were on Slice or Toast or any type app that I could at least put my order in electronically. Even if it’s just for pick up. I know it’s called Nostalgia, but I never miss the slight inconvenience of the calling in to place your order. Who doesn’t like ordering you food and paying in a few clicks? Aside from that very slight criticism, excellent restaurant! I’ll be trying full...

Last week my wife and I stopped into Nostalgia for dinner. Found the lace to be very clean and neat. The staff was very welcoming and friendly. We both ordered burgers. Our food arrived quickly, giant sized portions and cooked exactly as we ordered them. We probably should have split a dinner but we can never agree on toppings. We were very pleased with our visit. Took half of each order home, reheated the next day and it was still delicious. Will definitely go there again when we are...

I just wanted to take a moment to rave about the wings we ordered for SuperBowl Sunday… they were amazing! I’m sure they were very busy that day but they prepared them EXACTLY as I requested… extra crispy. We ordered Honey Hot, Mild, Teriyaki and Texas Chili. Delicious! And… even better- they know to keep the carrots and celery separate so they don’t get warm & soggy. The added bonus was the delicious chunky blue cheese dressing! Thanks...