FoxGardin Family Kitchen — Restaurant in Fishers

Truly blown away by our experience here...again! We came for a Valentine’s dinner on Saturday night and couldn’t have left any happier! The service was great...our server Brooke took such amazing care of us and she was on top of it all night even with a full section! She even took our picture at the end of the night and came back with it framed for us to take home....talk about wonderful customer service. So kind and heartwarming! ❤️ Brooke was great and when we come back, we will definitely ask for her again. Now let’s talk about the foooood because OMG everything was off the charts! We always get the bread as an appetizer bc we always love it. I tried the clam chowder tonight and it was some of the best i have ever had, so creamy and perfect. We ended up each getting a filet mignon cooked Medium. came out PERFECTLY cooked and oscar style which was amazing...i highly recommend! We didn’t do dessert, as we were so full after the fantastic dinners but next time we 100% will! The head chef, Josh, is incredible and knows what he’s doing!!! Couldn’t have enjoyed ourselves more tonight and so thankful we just moved down the street- we will be here...

I visited for the first time yesterday, I had high expectations based on reviews and word of mouth. My experience was very disappointing. The salads were prepped at least, 24 hours prior, the wedge was dry and lifeless with brown where the knife had passed, the bacon crumbles were the size of cracked pepper I had to use my readers to confirm it was on there. I was offered honey mustard as a dressing choice, what I received was straight yellow mustard, zero sweetness whatsoever. For $19 the pork belly hoagie was a total rip-off, the fennel was very bitter, chemical in flavor, the hoagie bun was very small, more like a roll, and only had 4 tiny pieces of pork belly on it. We were the only table in there and I was curious why the staff wasn't cleaning the dirty windows or sweeping the floor instead of staring at their phones. I went looking for the restroom and found a family restroom down a cluttered hallway, the light didn't work so I went looking for another, found the men's room which was quite dirty and out of soap and paper towels. The ONLY bright spot was the brussel sprout appetizer, it was delicious, but ask for an extra...

Great service, our server was super nice and attentive. Nice atmosphere. We ordered the calamari to start with, great flavor on the batter and the sauce was good but it was a bit chewy for our liking and not crispy. for entrees we got the tenderloin and fries which was 10/10!!! the shrimp linguine pesto, it tasted pretty good but was lacking a little in taste and was maybe a bit expensive for $30. the parmesan crusted chicken, mashed potatoes were awesome, chicken had nice flavor but the crust slid right off making it hard to get a good bite of everything (and that’s just nitpicking, it tasty). Overall though the entrees were good! If i had to suggest one thing not to order, it would be the side of “risotto”. I love risotto but this was like day old minute rice mixed with a bit of cream and parm. no flavor, weird texture, but maybe we got it on an off day. I had to mix it with other food because i hated to waste $6 but like i said, maybe it was just an off day. Definitely would come back for the great service, the tenderloin, and to try some of the other...