The Pizza Pie — Restaurant in Florida

No joke. This right here is easily the best pizza arround and it's not even close! When I say arround, its better then any NY style slice even in Tampa and only place that's as good is Gianni's in St Pete. The dough is so tasty and the sauce to die for.

Our 6 year old loves the Bakery style "Sicilian" (as do I for a change every so often) . Me and mom love the margarita (ask for parm and oregano when your order it). Im more of a well done pie guy, but the tastes here are brilliant. I will next time try a Pepperoni pie well done.

Also have tried the Stromboli (ham, pepperoni, spinach) and the cheese steak. Both are also excellent. 👍🏻👍🏻 Also the Greek salad and it's dressing are perfect to go along with a Pie.

Dont sleep on the entrees either. We have had the shrimp Alfredo and chicken Parm on Uber eats and both were fantastic and without over cooked shrimp which is hard to do on an Uber eats.

We stopped in for slices and the guy (owner I'm guessing) was a great guy and the place was BUSY for a Saturday afternoon (but HIGHLY efficient). Heard him tell a guy about his canolis and he said they are the best arround. He gave me one with the promise that if I like it I pay double, if I don't it's free. It was so good I told him I'm paying for it. He didn't charge use but I promise we will be ordering three on each visit. Tiramsu is next on our list.

The cannoli is also the best you'll fine arround here. Nice crispy shell and hand filled to order. Must add one to your order. Thank me later.

I spent more then 1/2 my life (32 years) eating apizza in Connecticut and know my pizza. (Pepes, Fuocco, Sally's, Modern in that order).

This is our local go to now. Consistant and just...

Edit June 2023: Hate to do it but had to drop a few stars on my original review. Idk what has changed here but the pizza has become a bit of a drag. Incredibly greasy the last few times we have ordered. I enjoy greasy but I am talking about seeping through the box before I get home greasy. I’m talking about getting a slice and holding it vertically and literally ounces of grease coming off. It’s bad. Not sure if ingredients changed or what but it was almost inedible the last 3 pizzas we have ordered. Easily have spent hundreds of dollars here over the last 6 months but will be taking a break to see if things improve next time. ———————- Have been here 3 times now and wanted to wait until the 3rd pie to give it a real review. I am so glad this place is here. The pizza is fantastic. Love to fold a nice pie and get a perfect bite. Wings were really good as well, which seems hard to find in the land o lakes area. They have been slammed and I am really glad they are getting the business.

Not even a complaint but the garlic knots weren’t that great. I would prefer they were more airy and doughy , more dense maybe.

Looking forward to ordering again soon. Thanks for bringing some great pizza...

Tucked away in the up & coming LOL area, The Pizza Pie is an unassuming gem serving authentic New York-style pizza worth every bite.

One step inside this cozy establishment, and you're transported to the pizzerias of the Empire State. The Pizza Pie's crust is thin yet sturdy - a hallmark of New York-style pizza. It's the perfect vehicle for their flavorful sauce, a beautifully robust concoction of ripe tomatoes, fresh herbs, and just the right hint of garlic. Topped with a blanket of perfectly melted, top-quality mozzarella, it's a pizza that would undoubtedly make any New Yorker feel at home.

The service at The Pizza Pie deserves special mention. The staff are friendly and genuinely passionate about serving their customers the perfect pizza experience.

The Pizza Pie is more than just a pizzeria. It's a slice of New York. For an authentic NY pizza experience without the flight, this is the spot you can't...