Home Plate Dairy — Restaurant in Franklin Township

This place has gone downhill bad. We have gone here for 7 years since moving out to Stewartsville. Updated 8-4-24 I would have given you the exact date and time, BUT you waited over 3 months to respond. And I did call to complain day of and was told “we’re busy, can’t please everyone” I get it, quantity over quality. Ice cream 4 miles down the road at the chuckling cow is way better anyway, and I can get crappy food with crappy service anywhere. Appreciate you making time months later for a response. Adds to the credibility of the review. Take care! Don’t bother anymore, not even worth the wait after the new ownership. I gave it a second shot for food after being terribly disappointed a month ago by a chicken nugget meal for my kids that was hardly cooked. Today we got fries and hot dogs and the fries were basically a lump of uncooked mashed potatoes in a platter, and the hot dogs were shriveled...

Hands down one of the best peach milkshakes I've had in a while. I also ordered their california burger and bbq sandwich + fries. The BBQ sandwich was very good, the bbq flavor tasted homemade and was served on a big soft Kaiser roll which absorbed some of the juice. It was good. Their fries tasted fresh and were cooked properly. I think they dont use salt on them which I think would make them better but they did ask if we wanted packets of salt and ketchup at the window. The California burger tasted fresh. The beef patties need a bit more flavoring in my opinion but the freshness of everything else made overlook that. Overall very good experience. Nice and open and they have outdoor sitting. Customer service ...

5-stars because they are one of the few ice cream places I discovered that had a sugarless flavor.

Lord have mercy. Not reduced sugar, or no sugar added. They said "no sugar." One flavor. My first ice cream in 3 years.

I'm not diabetic, but I do have the beginning of high blood sugar. Like many do.

This is a blessing to find this oasis.

Ok, maybe only one flavor...But that's better than nothing (if they were telling me the truth).

Maple Walnut ice cream -- bliss in a cup. I am certain I'm not alone. Big customer demographic being ignored by many ice cream establishments. Put a man on the moon but no one has sugarless ice cream.

No one except Home Plate Diary...who hit a ball out of the park the...